Before Vatican II, Catholics did not wear rosaries around their necks primarily because a rosary was viewed strictly as a sacred tool for prayer, not a piece of jewelry or a fashion accessory. Wearing one as a necklace was widely discouraged by the Church and religious orders to avoid trivializing a holy object.
1. The Rosary is a Sacramental, Not an Accessory
A rosary is a blessed sacramental designed specifically to count prayers and aid in meditative reflection. Church teaching (formalized in Canon 1171 of the Code of Canon Law) requires sacred objects to be treated with reverence and not employed for inappropriate or secular uses. Wearing it openly as a necklace risked reducing it to mere decoration, which the faithful and religious educators frowned upon. [1, 2, 3]
2. Traditional Methods of Carrying
Instead of being worn as jewelry, rosaries were traditionally kept out of sight in pockets, purses, or bags so they could be kept close at hand for quiet, spontaneous prayer throughout the day. Carrying them in this manner was a sign of personal devotion, keeping one connected to Mary and providing a soothing, pocket-sized reminder of faith. [1, 2]
3. Historical and Cultural Context
- Religious Orders: Certain orders like the Dominicans did wear large rosaries on their habits, but they were attached to the belt or cincture (the cord worn around the waist), rather than the neck. [1, 2]
- Persecution: During times of intense anti-Catholic persecution—such as in 16th and 17th century Ireland or England—public displays of the faith were banned. Catholics developed small, single-decade, or ring rosaries that could be hidden in the palm of a hand or pocket, establishing a long tradition of covert, pocket-based devotion.
1. Amazingly, just making a post with all-caps, all-bold, or a large font does not make the post true.
2. You are quoting from the
1983 Code -- You are citing the Code of 1983 which is...er...ambiguous at best in places. Are we just cherry-picking from the 1983 Code now?
3. Additionally, the Canon 1171 of the
Code of Canon Law says NOTHING -- as you are editorializing and claiming it does or making it sound like it does -- about rosaries whatsoever.
YOU DON'T get to "editorize" or "add to" the Code of Canon law to somehow try to make it apply to rosaries. The word "rosary" does not appear anywhere in the canons you refer to.
MEANWHILE, we DO have AMPLE EVIDENCE from St. Louis de Montfort's book -- that anyone can read and see in pdf form online -- that
open-carrying rosaries was normative throughout the 17th century and beyond.It is only in post-V2 world that openly wearing or displaying rosaries came to somehow become "frowned upon".
Topic: Benefits of Getting Fat (Read 11046 times)