Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Thinking about attending the CSPV instead of the SSPX  (Read 2903 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Re: Thinking about attending the CSPV instead of the SSPX
« Reply #25 on: Today at 04:05:10 AM »
Nice to know that Cabbage thinks he's the Recognize & Resist police on this forum.

His attitude and tone reminds me of something Pablo, the Santeria warlock would post when he was on CI.



It is necessary from your perspective to portray me this way. Because it makes you look like the calm and rational one.

Re: Thinking about attending the CSPV instead of the SSPX
« Reply #26 on: Today at 04:10:43 AM »
If you follow the logic of "any traditional Mass", then you are obliged to say that the crises in the Church is just about the Mass.
Sorry, is this comment directed at me?

Q: What logic exactly would one be following if he did his duty and accessed the sacraments provided to him at a Catholic Mass offered by a Catholic priest?
A: The Catholic faith and right reason.

Q: How would one be obliged to say that crisis in the Church is "just about the Mass" if one made a point of going to the Catholic Mass that God in his providence has provided for him/her nearest to ones home?
A: One isn't.

Q: Does the Church permit different views on the crisis in the Church, in particular the issue of what would happen if a Pope would fall into public heresy?
A: Yes, she does.

Q: Does the Church also teach that Catholics should maintain cordial relations with other Catholics even when they might disagree on disputed topics?
A: Yes she does. Christ also commands that Christians are to have fraternal charity amongst eachother for his sake.


Re: Thinking about attending the CSPV instead of the SSPX
« Reply #27 on: Today at 05:45:54 AM »
Sorry, is this comment directed at me?

Q: What logic exactly would one be following if he did his duty and accessed the sacraments provided to him at a Catholic Mass offered by a Catholic priest?
A: The Catholic faith and right reason.

Q: How would one be obliged to say that crisis in the Church is "just about the Mass" if one made a point of going to the Catholic Mass that God in his providence has provided for him/her nearest to ones home?
A: One isn't.

Q: Does the Church permit different views on the crisis in the Church, in particular the issue of what would happen if a Pope would fall into public heresy?
A: Yes, she does.

Q: Does the Church also teach that Catholics should maintain cordial relations with other Catholics even when they might disagree on disputed topics?
A: Yes she does. Christ also commands that Christians are to have fraternal charity amongst eachother for his sake.

You have no posts in this thread already, so how could it be directed at you?
So that's your first fail in logic right there.

You post is very strange also in the Q and A format. Mind explaining what that is about?

The Crisis in the Church is one of Faith. The change in the Mass is but a derivative of that. If Vatican II had been implemented but the Novus Ordo not, and the TLM was the norm for Catholics everywhere, then we would still be obliged to consecrate Bishops and stay away from the Conciliar authorities.

Because the supreme law of the Church is the salvation of souls. The greatest danger you can put yourself in is a danger to your Faith.

It is not a certain "ickiness" you feel if you are at a Novus Ordo. The reason you should not attend is because it is a danger to the faith. Not because it is a Sacrilege. Though that's important also.

Is that clear?