Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: SSPX Resistance for Dummies  (Read 1110 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

SSPX Resistance for Dummies
« on: May 05, 2026, 08:09:00 PM »
I made a paper called "the SSPX Resistance Argument for Dummies", detailing briefly in timeline form how the SSPX gradually made more and more compromises. The knowledge used for this paper comes from my reading of the book "As we are" by Sean Johnson. I haven't edited the paper yet, as I just finished it. I would like to find the most experienced, balanced, and impartial man possible to finish up the details of this paper while not making it too long. I can only post it through Google Docs, so if you want to edit it, then you will have to message me first for privacy's sake.

Offline Twice dyed

  • Supporter
Re: SSPX Resistance for Dummies
« Reply #1 on: May 05, 2026, 09:21:55 PM »
  Hi!  You have a good idea. I want to make a French paper too...if ...
I will suggest using neo-SSPX in your title., or similar... SSPX is a registered name. You might notice that the 'resistance' faithful still distinguish the SSPX as the "OLD", pre 2012 position, vs. the neoSSPX, lead by +F mostly, which is the institution seeking recognition from the Vatican. Many "resistants" assist at the neoSSPX, hoping that it finds its way back to the "Good 'ole SSPX.

  I bring this up because these upcoming consecrations are providing a huge opportunity for the neoSSPX to make known worldwide its Seminaries, Churches ( Many huge btw.), schools, pilgrimages, missions.  "They are making waves", would be an understatement.
Already there are hundreds of websites buzzing about the Exco, schism?. It will absolutely get frantic the sooner July 1 approaches.
Actually, we can't comprehend the implications: as Fr. Chazal said, the SSPX is big, it's really huge.

  So you publish a paper when the newSSPX is in its glory, in the spotlight, and they find out you are exposing their compromises etc, they might act forcefully, because they deride that term SSPX Resistance. CI users are still discussing what is the 'Resistance' really means anyway.
Adios.

Pope St.Pius V,  pray for us.+

Search Assist
Yes, the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) holds copyright over its content, which includes text, graphics, and multimedia on its websites. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution of this content is strictly forbidden.



Re: SSPX Resistance for Dummies
« Reply #2 on: May 05, 2026, 09:32:38 PM »
  Hi!  You have a good idea. I want to make a French paper too...if ...
I will suggest using neo-SSPX in your title., or similar... SSPX is a registered name. You might notice that the 'resistance' faithful still distinguish the SSPX as the "OLD", pre 2012 position, vs. the neoSSPX, lead by +F mostly, which is the institution seeking recognition from the Vatican. Many "resistants" assist at the neoSSPX, hoping that it finds its way back to the "Good 'ole SSPX.

  I bring this up because these upcoming consecrations are providing a huge opportunity for the neoSSPX to make known worldwide its Seminaries, Churches ( Many huge btw.), schools, pilgrimages, missions.  "They are making waves", would be an understatement.
Already there are hundreds of websites buzzing about the Exco, schism?. It will absolutely get frantic the sooner July 1 approaches.
Actually, we can't comprehend the implications: as Fr. Chazal said, the SSPX is big, it's really huge.

  So you publish a paper when the newSSPX is in its glory, in the spotlight, and they find out you are exposing their compromises etc, they might act forcefully, because they deride that term SSPX Resistance. CI users are still discussing what is the 'Resistance' really means anyway.
Adios.

Pope St.Pius V,  pray for us.+

Search Assist
Yes, the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX) holds copyright over its content, which includes text, graphics, and multimedia on its websites. Unauthorized reproduction or distribution of this content is strictly forbidden.
The paper is not intended for public publication; it will be used to send to people when they wonder what is wrong with the new SSPX. Also, the "search assist" thing you put here (which appears to me to be copy and pasted from an AI search engine, maybe it isn't though?) does not necessarily imply that the term SSPX itself is copyrighted. Besides, the term is meant to be put next to another term to create something new. The term neo-SSPX still has the term "SSPX" in it, which is in like manner to how I used the term. But, if I did decide to make it public, I would go ahead and change the name.

Offline Twice dyed

  • Supporter
Re: Origin , Timeline of the SSPX Resistance 2012 -2019
« Reply #3 on: June 01, 2026, 03:20:09 PM »
  Just in case someone needs a quick description of the SSPX-Resistance. This from Everybodywiki,
Here is the English.
  Kindda started when +Fellay signed his secret Declaration of Doctrine, April 15, 2012, when he wasn't concerned about the 2006 General Chapter rules (No agreement till Rome converts).

Then this long fire of a sermon by Fr J. Pfeiffer: Fr. Joseph Pfeiffer delivering a sizzling sermon on Pentecost, May 27, 2012...the spark that ignited an significant institutional meltdown.






These first Resistance bishops/priests weren't dummies.

Bishop Williamson, Bishop Faure (First choice for the 1988 Consecrations btw.), Bishop P Morgan, former District superior of England, Fr. P. Girouard,( Publisher of Communicantes, Convictions magazines of Canadian District ), Fr J. Pfeiffer (record holder for sending vocations to the seminary) etc....There was another priest in S. America who was rejected by the SSPX for his warnings against talks with Rome.  Fr Salenave;  Fr. Peter Scott, (former district Superior) is still with neoSSPX, but was sent to a remote corner of the globe.

****************
https://en.everybodywiki.com/SSPX_Resistance

  The SSPX Resistance is a loosely organized group of Traditionalist Catholics that grew out of the concern that the dialogue between the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) and the Holy See was leading the SSPX to accept the Second Vatican Council as a condition of the Society's recognition by Rome. The SSPX Resistance has continued to celebrate the Tridentine Mass and the pre-Vatican II (but post-Trent) rites, though independent of both the Catholic Church and the SSPX. They see themselves as holding true to the founding principles of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, opposing any drift towards liberalism and modernism perceived as having crept into the SSPX. The largest organisations of the SSPX Resistance are the Society of St. Pius X–Marian Corps (SSPX–MC) and the Union Sacerdotale Marcel Lefebvre.
Contents

    1 Origins
    2 2015, 2016, and 2017 consecrations
    3 See also
    4 References
    5 External links

Origins

  Though the dialogue with Rome ultimately failed in achieving reconciliation and recognition of the society, the possibility of further schism within the SSPX grew more serious. Bishop Williamson was the most prominent dissenter, challenging the authority and governance of the society publicly on multiple occasions. For example, in August 2012 Williamson administered the sacrament of Confirmation to about 100 lay people at the Benedictine Monastery of the Holy Cross in Nova Friburgo, Brazil, during an unauthorized visit to the State of Rio de Janeiro. The society's South American district superior, Father Christian Bouchacourt, protested his actions on the SSPX website saying that it was "a serious act against the virtue of obedience".[6]

  In early October the leadership of the SSPX gave Williamson a deadline to declare his submission, instead of which he published an "open letter" asking for the resignation of the superior general.[7] In October 2012 the society expelled Williamson in a "painful decision" citing the failures "to show respect and obedience deserved by his legitimate superiors".[8] Immediately after his expulsion, he publicly called for the establishment of a loose social network of what he called "Catholic Resistance" to any proposal by the society to drop its opposition to Rome.[1] Williamson served as the de facto bishop for various groups of the faithful and clergy sympathetic to Williamson and opposed to recent developments within the society.

  The most notable and largest group in North America began to call itself the Society of St. Pius X of the Strict Observance (SSPX-SO), though it is now known as the Society of St. Pius X–Marian Corps (SSPX–MC). Five priests; Fr. Joseph Pfeiffer, Fr. Ronald J. Ringrose, Fr. Richard Voigt, Fr. David Hewko and Fr. François Chazal; were either expelled from the SSPX or renounced their affiliation with the society, signing the "Vienna Declaration" and outlining their positions.[9] Since 2013, this group has become known by a number of names, including the Society of St. Pius X of the Strict Observance (SSPX-SO) and the Apostles of Jesus and Mary, but ultimately settled on the Society of St. Pius X–Marian Corps (SSPX–MC).[10] They are active, celebrating the Tridentine Mass and traditional form of the sacraments throughout Canada and the United States. Another group within the SSPX Resistance movement, in the Indian, East Asian, and Oceanic regions, uses the same name (SSPX-MC) and is served occasionally by priests affiliated with the North American SSPX-MC.[11] The SSPX-MC continues to follow the constitutions and rules of the Society of St. Pius X but provides a refuge for resistance priests and others who no longer believe they can fulfill their vows in the Society.

  Another group within the SSPX Resistance is the Union Sacerdotale Marcel Lefebvre (English: Priestly Union of Marcel Lefebvre), founded at the monastery of the Avrillé Dominicans in Avrillé, France.[12] Relations between the Society of St. Pius X and the Dominicans of Avrillé soured after certain religious in the community were suspected of aligning with the resistance. Bishop Fellay ultimately postponed ordinations scheduled for June 2014 as a test of loyalty.[13] On July 15, 2014, Bishop Williamson celebrated Mass at the monastery and presided over the meeting and organization of French priests associated with the SSPX Resistance.[14] Thereafter, the Dominican Friars of Avrillé formally declared their disassociation with the SSPX and, together with other French SSPX Resistance priests, formed the Priestly Union of Marcel Lefebvre by a "Declaration of Catholic Fidelity", signed October 26, 2014.[15]

  In 2013, a non-profit (501C3) organisation was set up under the title "St. Marcel Initiative", a trade name of BRN Associates, Inc.[16] This initiative of independent pockets of resistance without hierarchical structure[1] is patronized by Richard Williamson and overseen by David Allen White.[3][4]
2015, 2016, and 2017 consecrations

  On March 19, 2015, Bishop Williamson consecrated Bishop Jean-Michel Faure at the Benedictine Monastery of the Holy Cross in Nova Friburgo, Brazil.[17] Father Faure, a Frenchman, was one of the first members of the Society of St. Pius X and was even initially considered for the episcopacy by Marcel Lefebvre in the 1988 consecrations, though Faure turned down the selection; Fellay was chosen in his place. Faure served the society as district superior of both Argentina and Mexico for many years.[17] While both had already been expelled from the society, the SSPX condemned the consecration.[18]

  On March 19, 2016, one year after the 2015 consecration, Bishop Williamson consecrated Miguel Ferreira da Costa (aka Thomas Aquinas) of Brazil at the same place. The SSPX did not comment on the new consecration.[19] On May 11, 2017, it was announced that Williamson intended to consecrate a third bishop, Mexican-American prelate Gerardo Zendejas. The consecration was held at St. Athanasius Church in Vienna, Virginia.[20]


References

    "And Now?". Eleison Comments (277). St. Louis, MO: St. Marcel Initiative. 2012-11-03. Retrieved 2019-01-23. "God […] wants a loose network of independent pockets of Resistance, gathered around the Mass, freely contacting one another, but with no structure of obedience such as served to sink the mainstream Church in the 1960s, and is now sinking the Society of St Pius X." — Quoted, but without identifying the source of information, by: West, Ed (2012-11-09). "Expelled bishop urges network of 'Catholic resistance'". The Catholic Herald. Archived from the original on 2018-11-06. Retrieved 2019-02-04 – via Exact Editions.
    "Note from the Secretary of State concerning the four Prelates of the Society of Saint Pius X (February 4, 2009)". La Santa Sede. 2009-02-04. Archived from the original on 2018-11-06. Retrieved 2018-09-12. "A full recognition of the Second Vatican Council and the Magisterium of Popes John XXIII, Paul VI, John Paul I, John Paul II and Benedict XVI himself is an indispensable condition for any future recognition of the Society of Saint Pius X." — Cf. Richard Williamson's arguments against sedevacantism: "Church's Infallibility – I". Eleison Comments (343). St. Louis, MO: St. Marcel Initiative. 2014-02-08. Retrieved 2019-01-16. — "Church's Infallibility – II". Eleison Comments (344). St. Marcel Initiative. 2014-02-15. Retrieved 2019-01-16. — "Again, Sedevacantism – I". Eleison Comments (response to Donald Sanborn) (481). St. Louis, MO: St. Marcel Initiative. 2016-10-01. Retrieved 2019-01-17. — "Sedevacantism Again – II". Eleison Comments (response to Donald Sanborn) (482). St. Louis, MO: St. Marcel Initiative. 2016-10-08. Retrieved 2019-01-17. "Sedevacantists are thinking humanly, all too humanly."
    "Don Curzio Nitoglia-Libri-Video-Testi-Audio". 2012-11-03. Archived from the original on 2019-01-23. Retrieved 2019-01-23. "St. Marcel Initiative […] An Endeavour for all purposes of the Catholic Resistance Patronized by His Excellency Bishop Richard Williamson" Italian: "Iniziativa San Marcel […] Un impegno per tutti i fini della Resistenza Cattolica patrocinato da Sua Eccellenza Mons. Richard Williamson".
    "David Allen White" (biography). St. Louis, MO: St. Marcel Initiative. Archived from the original on 2018-12-21. Retrieved 2019-01-26. "David Allen White is Vice Chairman of BRN Associates, Inc., and spokesman for the St. Marcel Initiative. […] Dr. White, on behalf of and in conjunction with His Excellency Bishop Williamson, acts as the "public face" of the St. Marcel Initiative, handling much of its official correspondence and bearing responsibility for the release, as approved by the Bishop, of news and announcements regarding His Excellency's activities." — "Brn Associates Inc". Williamsburg, VA: GuideStar. Archived from the original on 2019-01-26. Retrieved 2019-01-26. "Principal Officer: Patrick McCarthy […] Main Address: […] Glenelg, MD […] Cause Area (NTEE Code): Roman Catholic (X22)" .
    "St. Marys Kansas Resistance | Resisting The New Direction Of The SSPX". St. Marys Kansas Resistance. Archived from the original on 2019-01-20. Retrieved 2019-02-04.
    "Bishop causes more controversy for breakaway Catholic group". Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Communiqué of the General House of the Society of Saint Pius X (October 24, 2012) | DICI". www.dici.org. Archived from the original on 2012-10-27. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Communiqué of the General House of the Society of Saint Pius X (October 24, 2012) | DICI". www.dici.org. Archived from the original on 2012-10-27. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Declaration LeFebvre Priests Vienna, Virginia". www.cathinfo.com. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Marian Corps (SSPX-MC)" (PDF). Ecclesia Militans. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Information on the Society of St. Pius X Marian Corps (SSPX MC) in India and East Asia". SSPX (MC) India, East Asia, and Oceania. Archived from the original on 2015-04-23. Retrieved 2018-06-16.
    "France fidèle | Le site officiel français de l'Union Sacerdotale Marcel Lefebvre". France fidèle. Archived from the original on 2015-05-11. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Christus Vincit! Christus Regnat! Christus Imperat! :: L'abbé de Cacqueray, un homme d'exception". christusvincit.clicforum.com. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Priestly UNION SURGE MARCEL LEFEBVRE!". Cor Mariae. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Déclaration de fidélité catholique quarante ans après celle de 1974". Dominicains Avrillé. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "St. Marcel Initiative" (official website). St. Louis, MO. 2019-01-12. Archived from the original on 2019-01-03. Retrieved 2019-01-23.
    "The Recusant – Fr Faure". The Recusant. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Consecration of Fr. Jean-Michel Faure". SSPX – District of the USA. Archived from the original on 2015-05-06. Retrieved 2015-05-21.
    "Third Bishop". Eleison Comments (453). St. Louis, MO: St. Marcel Initiative. 2016-03-19. Retrieved 2019-01-23.
    "Statement from the Most Reverend Michael F. Burbidge on the Consecration of Father Gerardo Zendejas, Member of an Independent Church". Roman Catholic Diocese of Arlington. May 19, 2017. Retrieved January 23, 2018.

External links

    SSPX - Marian Corps
    St. Marcel Initiative
    SSPX Resistance - Facebook Page
    The Recusant - SSPX Resistance News
    The traditional Dominicans of Avrille
    CathInfo - SSPX Resistance Discussion Forum






Offline Twice dyed

  • Supporter

https://everybodywiki.com/R%C3%A9sistance_(FSSPX)
Resistance (FSSPX)

AI Translation from the French. Some different info.
Warning: this is a really old article, developments now occurring weekly.
Also, keep in mind that there are groups supporting the "SSPX-Resistance", but never belonged to the " SSPX ".
One key requirement to be Resistance is to attαck the enemies of the Roman Catholic Church... Exposing their errors and anti-Catholic teachings, doubtful sacraments and a long list of scandals...

**********************
  The résistance“resistance” or anti-accordist movement is a traditionalist current that is distinguished by its opposition to any form of reconciliation between the Lefebvrist [1]circles[1] and the papacy. Originally from the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X (FSSPX), some of these supporters left the latter under the superior Mgr Fellay, considered too close to Rome].[2]
Summary

    1 History
    2 Organization
    3 Currents
    4 Publications
    5 To deepen
        5.1 Bibliography
        5.2 Related articles
        5.3 External links
    6 Notes and References

History
 This section needs to be updated (July 2018).
Reorganization and clarification of content is necessary. ...

  In April 2012, a letter[[3] written by M gr Bernard Tissier de Mallerais, Mr Richard Williamson and Mgr Alfonso de Galarreta, three of the four bishops consecrated by M gr Marcel Lefebvre, addressed to Mr Bernard Fellay, superior of the Priestly Fraternity of Saint-Pie-X, expressed their opposition[[4] to a practical agreement with the Holy See.

  Bp. Richard Williamson is the first to oppose each other frontally: in August 2012, he gave the sacrament of confirmation to the Benedictine monastery of Nova Friburgo, without the agreement of the superior of the district of South America. His attitude openly hostile to the opening line[[5] chosen by Mr Bernard Fellay led to his expulsion in October 2012[6].[6]

  In the perspective of a canonical agreement between the Holy See and the SSPX, an opposition was also developing on the part of priests in 2012.[[7] Four religious communities, the Monastery of the Holy Cross (Brazil), the Monastery of St. Joseph (Colombia, then Ecuador) founded in 2013, the Institute of Our Lady of the Rosary (Brazil), the Servants of Mary, Queen of Peace (Brazil) and the Carmelite Saint-Joseph (Germany)[[8] have severed ties with the leadership of the SSPX.

  In the United States, where the current is identified under the name Society of St. Pius X of the Strict Observance (SSPX-SO), five newly expelled priests from the SSPX signed [9]a statement in Vienna, Virginia in August 2012.[9]

  In Asia and Oceania, around the personality of Father Chazal in the Philippines, the group is referred to as the Company of Mary (Marian Corps of Saint Pius X. 9MC SPX).

In January 2014, more than fifty priests make up this opposition[[10], and the text of an Address to the faithful[[11], notably signed by the Dominicans of Avrillé (Fraternité Saint-Dominique)[12]], circulates in the churches and chapels of Tradition. In July 2014, priests expelled from the SSPX gave birth to the Marcel-Lefebvre Priestly Union (USML), with the support of M gr Williamson and the active participation of the Dominicans of Avrillé].13]

  On March 19, 2015, Jean-Michel Faure was consecrated bishop by M gr Williamson:

    At the beginning of 2013, he left the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius to join the ranks of the opponents in the rapprochement with Rome and was officially excluded from the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius X in 2014;
    On March 19, 2015, he received the episcopal consecration from the hands of M Richard Williamson at the Monastery of Santa Cruz in Nova Friburgo, Brazil, without pontifical authorization, but with a mandate of substitution, self-proclaimed and not signed by the conciliar authorities, which is read during the ceremony, as had been done for the sacred bishops in 1988 by Mr. Lefeb. This episcopal consecration is also similar to that of M gr Licinio Rangel by three bishops of the SSPX in 1991. He is therefore excommunicated by Rome, as well as Richard Williamson, excommunication laetae sententiae (by the simple fact of the act performed) for having "performed an illegitimate act"[14]],,[16]][17]],][18]. He later returned to France to found a seminary under the patronage of Saint Louis-Marie Grignion de Montfort and Blessed Noël Pinot, who opened in Angers on October 3, 2015. The management is provided by Jean-Michel Faure and the brothers of the Fraternité Saint-Dominique of the convent of the Hague-aux-Bonshommes are part of the teaching staff.[réf. nécessaire]

  In July 2015, it is the turn of the Knights of Our Lady - Observance of the Holy Hearts of Jesus and Mary to join the anti-accordist current.

  On March 19, 2016, the two bishops sacred Bishop Miguel Ferreira da Costa (Dom Thomas of Aquinas), Prior of Santa Cruz].[19] In May 2017[20], the three bishops conswcrated a fourth bishop, Gerardo Zendejas[21] ]in the United States.

  In December 2017, Bishop Richard Williamson ordained a first priest for the Priestly Society of the Apostles of Jesus and Mary (SAJM), Father Rodrigo Ribeiro da Silva.[22][23]] A few months later, Father Rodrigo Ribeiro da Silva was expelled because of sedevacantism].24]

  For Jean-Marie Guénois, the ousting of Mr Fellay and the election of Father Pagliarani at the head of the SSPX in July 2018 would be partly due to the influence of the "resistants" within the Fraternity. According to him, this seems all the more likely that Mgr de Galarreta and Abbé Christian Bouchacourt, superior of the district of France, were elected "assistants" of the new superior.[25]]

In July 2019, it had four bishops and a hundred affiliated priests].26]
Organization

This network of chapels is organized mainly through structures voluntarily[27],[28] ]atomized to avoid any centralization:

    SSPX-CM[29] (2012) by Father Pfeiffer.
    Compagnie de Marie (CM) or SSPX-MC[30] (2012) regional superior Father François Chazal[31]
    Priestly Society of the Apostles of Jesus and Mary[32] SAJM (2016) erected by M gr Faure
    Marcel-Lefebvre Union USML (2014-2017). Three members, by sedevacant option, decided to dissolve on 6 July 2017.[33]]

Currents

There are three groups:

    The main compound of priests who support the four bishops.
    The priests or faithful sedevacantists, this is the case of Father Fernando Altamira in Colombia, three priests and Carmel of St. Joseph in Germany, of the Abbot Arnold Trauner[34] ]in Austria, of the abbot Ramiro Martín Ribas[35] in Spain, of the abbots Nicolas Pinaud and Olivier Rioult[[36] in France, or the abbot Pierre Roy[37] (...)in Canada
    In opposition to Bishop Richard Williamson and the three other bishops but not sédévacantist, in particular Father Joseph [Pfeiffer[39] and his former American acolyte Fr. David Hewko[40], Abbé Martin [Fuchs[41] in Austria and the Czech Republic as well as Father Ernesto Cardozo[42]] in Brazil and the monastery of Saint-Joseph[43]] in Mexico of Father Rafael[44]