Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: What is objectionable about a woman driving one of the opposite gender to Mass?  (Read 3248 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

I am curious to know why it is that a lady today at an SSPX chapel offered me a ride home, but then said she should ask the priest first it was OK for her to do that!

There must be something I am blissfully unaware of...

Well there's nothing wrong with it if the pair were husband and wife, or brother/sister. Otherwise a man and woman should not be alone in a car


Offline Ladislaus

  • Supporter
Yes, it was probably due to the possibility of scandal.  St. Pius X would not sit in the same carriage with a woman ... for that reason.  When I was a seminarian, I had to give a lady a ride home and she rode in the back seat.

So what does one do when their supervisor asks them to give them a lift to pick up their car at the mechanic? Hypothetical of course.  :)

Offline Ladislaus

  • Supporter
So what does one do when their supervisor asks them to give them a lift to pick up their car at the mechanic? Hypothetical of course.  :)

It all depends on whether there's any risk of scandal.  Could people who know you're married to someone else and yet do not know the purpose for the trip draw some conclusion about it?  If the only ones who see you are people who know that you're just dropping him off to get his car, the risk of scandal is minimal.  If no one who might see you knows that you're married to someone else, the risk of scandal is minimal.  After all, you could just be a couple (married to each other even).  If there's a 30-year age difference between the two of you, the risk of scandal is minimal.  But let's say I'm a married 35-year-old man riding with a 35-year-old woman and driving past people who know me and my wife, and they don't know why I'm in the car with this woman, i.e., the reason for the trip isn't known or otherwise obvious, the risk of scandal increases, with people wondering "Are they having an affair?"  It's just a question of prudence:  How likely is it that someone who sees you might conclude that you're having an affair?  Also factoring in is how long are you gone?  So, even if a woman who worked in my office asked me for a ride, and everyone knew I was just giving her a ride to get her car, it's no big deal ... unless of course I'm gone for 3 hours without explanation.  But if I'm back in 15-20 minutes, then no conclusions would be drawn.