I thought this was an important point in another thread, a bottom line, and worthy of it's own thread for discussion:
...Bishop Fellay, Fr Rostand might as well join the FSSP if that is the case.Diocesan Bishops for confirmations will be the norm for this Neo SSPX.
That is the bottom line, there is no difference between the FSSP and the Neo-SSPX.
If we obey, follow Fr. Rostand's line of thinking, then we would be nuts to go through all the work we do to have the mass. We should have just switched over to the local Indult mass, Eastern Rite Mass, or conservative Novus Ordo, back in 1988.
Anyone that believes what Fr. Rostand says and still goes through all the expense and work of building and maintaining chapels, buying houses and maintaining them for the preists to live, buying cars, paying airfare, feeding the priests, mowing the lawns etc., would have to be a lunatic.
If concilarist Rome has valid bishops, valid priest, valid sacraments, and a valid mass, why should someone go through all that work at an SSPX chapel, when they can just show up every Sunday (or weekday) at the local Indult mass, Eastern Rite Mass, or conservative Novus Ordo, put $1 in the basket and leave without having to raise a finger to work?