Author Topic: What Exactly is the Difference Between the Recent Consecrations and 1988? (Read 578 times)

Twice dyed · « **Reply #15 on:** **Yesterday** at 02:21:41 PM »

Thank you for the background of this priest. Good to know he was at one time resistance.

Which other differences does he discuss?

Giovanni Berto · « **Reply #16 on:** **Yesterday** at 06:38:11 PM »

Quote from: Twice dyed on Yesterday at 02:21:41 PM

Thank you for the background of this priest. Good to know he was at one time resistance.

Which other differences does he discuss?

His argument revolves around three points:

- Abp. Lefebvre did not recognize Modernist Popes after 1988, saying that JPII was excommunicated.

- He did not recognize the Modernist organization as the Catholic Church, calling it "bastard church".

- They have no reason to consecrate bishops, since they recognize the Modernist sacraments and hierarchy as valid.

On the second half he goes on to talk about tangential topics, like condemning those who use the pre-1955 Holy Week (even calling them heretics!). He considers the liturgy as infallible, including the 1955 changes, which I believe is not accurate.

Twice dyed · « **Reply #17 on:** **Yesterday** at 10:19:20 PM »

Thanks GB.
...there are 360 degrees in a circle, and depending on the angle/perspective one takes, there must be at least 360 opinions on this topic.

I wonder when Fr. Schmidberger will write something...he is part of the neo-SSPX top brass. He's gotta be thinking, all the priceless media coverage (FREE) to promote the SSPX; they are gambling.
The moment neo-SSPX had "+Huonder" confecting the sacraments on Holy Thursday 2023, there was , implicitly, no "State of Necessity" to consecrate bishops.
As Fr Girouard explained: these people aren't logical.

Focusing on their B R A N D is a major undertaking. Did their Logo appear on those 'Souvenir Wine Bottles"?
Tomorrow they will offer round bottles branded Brandy, cuve de Boregonezz 'eau *'.
50 degrees spirits, 50 personna "other" bland.

_______________
* water [f*ke brandy]

CathInfo.com

Author Topic: What Exactly is the Difference Between the Recent Consecrations and 1988? (Read 578 times)

Twice dyed

Re: What Exactly is the Difference Between the Recent Consecrations and 1988?

Giovanni Berto

Re: What Exactly is the Difference Between the Recent Consecrations and 1988?

Twice dyed

Re: What Exactly is the Difference Between the Recent Consecrations and 1988?