Nice try. There was no dispute over the practice of the Church in relation to sketchy Sacraments in the past, which rules out the Thuc line.
And the modernism is clearly a bad thing. So that rules out those to our left.
Of course, His Excellency Guérard des Lauriers was less qualified in theology than you, he couldn't even ascertain whether Bp Thuc line's and sacraments were doubtful or not.


Let's compare the academic pedigree of Bp Guérard des Lauriers and Tom. On the one hand, we have a doctor in theology with a math Phd. On the other hand, we got a NEET. I wonder whose opinion a Catholic should listen to.