I know several people who use this type of option, and are very happy with it.
Not to be flip, but many people are also happy with Kaiser (the HMO archetype).
Those people fall mostly into two categories:
(1) young healthy people who take care of themselves, don't get sick, so never need to deal with Kaiser's obstructions and
(2) people with catastrophic medical problems who have been successfully plugged into Kaiser's system and all the costs are borne within Kaiser (as Kaiser dictates, "
our way or
no way").
Unfortunately, most people and most families are in the middle of those extremes, families with some health problems, so have to negotiate the roadblocks and maze of requirements that lead, last time I saw numbers,
70% of Kaiser patients pay out-of-pocket for care outside of Kaiser. So, that 70% pays their Kaiser premiums, Kaiser is out of pocket nothing, and the patients has the additional expense of using the provate system, e.g., "urgent care cebters" and the like.
I looked at the Protestant (not "Christian") plans and concluded it was just a variant of Kaiser's roadblocks and mazes. We took the "get a job that provides…" option.