CathInfo.com

You believe that I'm an SSPX troll because I see merit in the talks of Fr. Purdy?

It's true that I do not believe that all SSPX are bad, as you evidently do. I don't think that the four Resistance bishops think that all of the SSPX priests are bad. IMO, they understand the virtue of charity and hope. They are quite different from Plinio de Oliveira in this regard.

So far, in the videos of Fr. Purdy here, I haven't seen that he has complained about the problems with the TIA/disciples of Plineo. Perhaps he is more concerned about other things than criticizing the TIA/disciples of Plinio. I cannot speak for him, and maybe I'm wrong, but perhaps he doesn't see everyone who disagrees with his views as an enemy.

Lady Meg,

Fr. Purdy cares far more about his SSPX "political mission" to undermine TIA/TFP than the historical & spiritual significance of the Quito Shrine.

As most trads know, the SSPX has no scholarship or scholars. They use 3rd party sources or home-grown sycophants, like Fr. Robinson.

The SSPX's Quito campaign is slick, utilizing their Dutch branding co. and conciliar marketing resources.

newChurch obviously wants to give them an entre' into the major Marian Shrines for the prestige, publicity and money they'll need to posture as the leaders of tradition.

Your argumentation ignores the scholarly contribution TIA gave to the Catholic world about a Marian Devotion that had been purposefully buried by Quito's notorious Freemasonic lodges.

Even Menzingen was clueless about Quito until they read TIA's works.

So, if you don't perceive yourself as helping the SSPX cause, go hang-out with Jade Liboro.  She and Fr. Purdy are probably so happy with you, they will buy you lunch.

As the New Yorker, Father Purdy said, his view of "success" means winning the Lotto.

Since the SSPX dropped the vow of poverty for their holy religious , it means he could then buy a nice new pickup truck.



For his Philippino fans, it may mean winning the US Green Card lottery?

For Catholics introduced to the Devotion of Our Lady of Good Success by Dr. Marian and Atila, it means confidence that Our Lady will intercede to bring success to our earnest & prayerful intentions if they are deserving in the Eyes of God.

Your remarks about fr Purdy are low-class. Is this site a place for us to post issues and good Catholic insight or to compete with each other on who can be the most degenerate in ridiculous gossips and name calling?
By the way: Society priests never took the vow of poverty... They are a 'society of common life without vows' as founded by the Archbishop.

Cera has some neurotic mental imbalance when it comes to the TFP.  She clearly has some grudge against them but refuses to come clean about what this is.  She sees a TFP member behind every bush.

Ad hominem attacks are not only a logical fallacy, they are also the last refuge of someone who has no argument.

Just fyi, I have never been in a SSPX chapel, and I don't know any SSPX priests.

In regard to shills, look in the mirror buddy. You and your TIA/TFP pals never bother to look at the links provided -- you just continue to shill for Plinio, Atila and Marian.

I do pray for you, as I pray for all those caught up the Plinio- worshiping cults.