The reason for Fr. Anthony leaving the CMRI had nothing to do with BOD. He departed rebelliously from the religious house, which was the culmination of repeated acts of disobedience and defiance, and showing no signs of amendment despite regular admonitions. He then found a home with Fr. Dominic Crawford (ordained by Bp. Webster, if Webster's orders are valid, and if we can trust Webster didn't botch that ordination also). It was not until after leaving the CMRI and associating with Fr. Crawford that Fr. Anthony began to reject BOD.
Sounds like fr. Anthony and Fr. Pfeiffer are kindred spirits, perhaps fr. Crawford, too...