Quote from: JayneK
Yes, I am disgusted by the person who stalked and outed Clare. But that does not make it OK for Clare to post on a porn site. No Catholic - male, female, trans, hetero or homo sɛҳuąƖ - ought to be posting on that site. And it does not make it OK for her to portray herself as a chaste, practicing Catholic here and a sɛҳuąƖly active transwoman there. I am less concerned by Clare's alleged sɛҳuąƖ sins than by her apparent hypocrisy and dishonesty.
If someone is struggling with sɛҳuąƖ sins, I am pleased to offer my compassion and prayers. I struggle too. But a person who claims to be chaste on one forum while writing smut on another is leading a double life. It is very wrong.
I don't think she claimed to be chaste at all (I don't remember the topic ever coming up aside from her having said that she'd rethink the idea of marriage. And perosnally, I think it'd be tacky to ask someone about her sex life on a forum like this). And I haven't seen the site in question, though I've deleted links to it throughout this thread and was given a description of what was there, so don't know if it was a "porn site" or a dating site. Whatever the case, Clare knows what Catholic teaching is, and all of us do, too. I pray she does the right things in life and stays close to Christ.
I don't see anything in her actions that make her "hypocritical". Just a human being, a sinner, like most of us. I mean, it's one thing to know what Church teaching is and to uphold it (as Clare always has here), and to have ideals, but it doesn't make one a "hypocrite" to fall short in living perfectly. Most of us don't, whether its' sɛҳuąƖ sins, money sins, gossips sins like what's going on at other forums when it comes to all this, etc. As an ex., I miss Mass a lot but I'm not a "hypocrite" because I affirm and intellectually assent to what the Church teaches and don't judge others if they miss Mass sometimes, too. KWIM? I see that as the same as Clare's situation. She's never, that I know of, contradicted Church teaching or told anyone not to uphold it. She's never portrayed herself as perfect or a non-sinner in any way. She's just another Catholic trying to get through life, presumably failing sometimes, like most of us do. I think it's unreasonable to expect a Catholic to refrain from posting at Catholic forums unless that person reveals all his sins and failings as he goes along. This isn't a Confessional, eh?
I dunno... Whoever is trying to dig up dirt on her and engage in detraction against her is committing a great evil. I think it's sad and disgusting -- yes, even more disgusting than whatever she could have posted at whatever site.
There are some serious, card-carrying LIBERALS on Fisheaters, and I'm not just throwing around buzz-words or hyperbole.
Loggats is a good example of this.
Vox's latest post (above) is a classic example of someone with liberal mind-rot, whose mind has come unhinged -- not unlike what has happened to many in the conciliar church as a result of Modernism.
She has lost touch with common sense, reason, objective reality, etc.
Such a one you can pray for...and that's about it. You certainly can't argue with them.
Topic: Is one of the posters at fisheaters a transɛҳuąƖ? (Read 93539 times)