Friends, I often advertise on my local Craigslist and ask if anyone has old Catholic items that are no longer being used. I generally keep the rarer books as 'insurance' against the closings or ccomplete sellouts of my regional Catholic stores. Other items like inexpensive plastic figures or plastic Rosaries are donated to local churches or hospital chapels.
Beyond that, I have several very beautiful vintage Rosaries and some other sacramentals that I find lovely, but I just don't have the room or need for them all.
If anyone would be interested in trading for any of these items, let me know in this thread. I'm always looking for statues, traditional books and pamphlets and so on.