In the meantime, this speculative theory only causes harm. It erodes people's believe in the necessity of Baptism. As Father Feeney put it, believing in Baptism of Desire actually would undermine one's ability to achieve this state, since instead of ardently desiring the Sacrament (which would be required), one becomes complacent that one might attain justification without the actual Sacrament.
Not only, it also causes harm to who is on his journey back into the Catholic Church.
If a reformist Catholic becomes aware of the conflict between reformist Catholics and Catholics, and discovers that some of the most preeminent areas of contention are ecuмenism and kingship, then BoD becomes a critical doctrine.
If Catholics concede to the doctrine of BoD, logically, this doctrine can be used as a powerful tool for reformist Catholics to argue that, then, the VII reforms are only expressions of a Catholic truth and VII only consolidates accepted Catholic doctrine. VII becomes a mere pastoral consequence of a theological truth.
To those like me who are walking home, this doctrine is really critical.
If accepted it instills doubt in our hearts and can make us waiver... I did. I asked God to enlighten me while I was walking to receive Holy Eucharist this Sunday and, I faltered. I faltered because I had been reading this thread and I feared that I was believing an error that placed me in a state of sin and, therefore, I could not communicate myself.
If Catholics concede ground in one of the principal areas of contention between Catholics and Reformist Catholics, then shy faithful who are doubtful and hesitant may draw the wrong conclusion that all this crisis is merely a lot of fuss about nothing: why would ecuмenism and diluted kingship be a problem, if BoD were to be a true doctrine? Ecuмenism and diluted kingship are a mere, tangible, expression of BoD.
... CUT ...
we must hold that non-Catholics and infidels can be inside the Church. This is in fact Vatican II ecclesiology in a nutshell.
... CUT ...
But I see the fruits of this doctrine, and the fruits of Vatican II, a widescale massive RELIGIOUS INDIFFERENTISM.
I agree. I was completely indifferent to doctrines, precepts, etc..
I am but a student and my knowledge of Catholic doctrine is weak and this is
because I believed that I could and would be saved anyway even if I did not bother to adhere to Catholic precepts and doctrine. All I needed for salvation was true intent to love God, and all these petty, material, visible requirements of the Church were unnecessary. God did not need the bureaucracy and formalities of the Church because, in reality, God was only in my heart = BoD.
I was convinced that God would save me anyway as long as I worshiped him, and even if I worshipped him in my own way rather than how the Church taught. These anthropocentric teachings deny God's kingship and teach caritas before veritas. I remember, distinctly, a priest teaching from the pulpit that veritas before caritas hurts God. I remember being taught that God loves me even if I don't (True) and will save me even if I'm not a practicing Catholic (false). First of all there is no such thing as a practicing and non practicing Catholic but also a practicing Catholic may be damned if he dies in a state of mortal sin even if he is a perfectly good person but denies that, for example, Jesus is God, as a jew or muslim would.
In short, I was truly convinced that salvation did not require adhering to precepts and doctrines but merely required me to be a good person with honest love of God = BoD.
This is why I contend that denouncing BoD as false, especially to reformist Catholics, is crucial to the Catholic cause.
I think that #1 is better stated to say that God saves all who are saved. He invites all into His Vineyard, which is the Church. All those who choose to enter into it and labor, will receive their reward as your #2 says. Whereas through a BOD, man saves himself.
I agree that it is more accurate to say that God can save anyone, by bringing anyone into his vineyard. Thank you for correcting me. I need help to walk home along the right path.