Who here said he should call her his enemy or rule with an iron fist?? what? Stop projecting.
Well, since so many posts are anonymous in here, I don't actually know who said what most of the time. But the constant rhetoric of "she's manipulating you", "she's not a traditional Catholic", and so forth encourages a hostile and combative approach to the problem-- which is the approach one uses with enemies. If people have overstated their case then that is their problem, not mine for taking their word.
.
From what I'm seeing, the problem is not going to go away. She will keep doing what she is doing. If the husband doesn't want her to do something like what she is doing, and its reasonable (which this scenario, him asking her to stop it is) she needs to listen to him. You can't reason with this stupidity. It's either that or he gets walked on.
.
I agree the problem is not going to go away. But it also isn't going to be solved in a moment of authoritizing harder. This woman already doesn't respect her husband's authority. And I don't think that's all that uncommon, even for traditional women, when they first set out in marriage.
When my wife has anxiety about something or is upset, we definitely talk about it. If my wife started throwing apple cores around the room because it's "healthy", she is going to stop it because I said so. This kinda proves women are adult children. Men don't get away with this BS.
.
Yes, men and women are different. We do not hold women to the standards of men. They are more like children than men are. Like children, they respond best to love. This is why St. Paul's injunction to husbands is to
love their wives, something that doesn't come all that naturally-- just as wives respecting their husbands doesn't come all that naturally. You sound like you're just seizing on OP's woes to issue general complaints. Fine, but your general complaints by no means make for good advice for his situation.