CathInfo.com

No, it's really not.  It's not even Top 30 on the list...for catholics, that is.

That's all you can do- personal attacks, straw men, pettifoggery, whatever kind of distraction necessary. It's obviously important to you, because you post about it constantly. I think your claim about the Top 30 is a lie even for you. We don't see you posting constantly about the spiritual life, the closeness of death, and the necessity of stamping out sin the soul. But rather, we see that you constantly add to your own shame in the next life by relentlessly smearing opponents of Russia by whatever means you can manage.

Since we've exposed the lie, I can say that yes, in geopolitics and for those of us with families, World War III and destabilization of our countries is one of our top concerns. This could be understood in the proper context for those of good will.

We've discussed this before. Communism is just one movement that the Elites use to enslave humanity. They aren't stupid enough to actually believe in its tenets.

I have posted this on the board before. Communism is an effective tool for achieving power. This has nothing to do with what I am talking about.

Let's break down the next part.

You still believe that we trads who do not have the right to question your beliefs.

I believe you made a typo here, but the idea is still false. In fact, the pro-Russian faction on the forum is very intolerant of dissenting beliefs. They would prefer that the Russian POV is the default and have stated so repeatedly.

I've been posting on trad forums for about 20 years. Trads generally do NOT take your POV.

1.) You can't prove this at all. It's based on your perception of the noisiest members on the board. It is true that Resistance members are more susceptible to Russian propaganda, but there is an understandable reason for it.

2.) The US population at large does not support Russia or China. The percentage of Catholics who are not Novus Ordo conservatives and who belong to the Traditional Catholic movement are a minority. The number of people who are SSPX Resistance adherents are an even fainter minority still.

3.) The best that can be said of this statement is that it is wishful thinking and anecdotal. Your next statement really applies better to it than what you believe about me.

You have the minority opinion, and it is not a logical opinion.

For the most part, as described above, false. There is a loud brigade that occupies this forum and hounds people in general for dissenting views, especially concerning Russia. In addition to what I said above about the SSPX Resistance in particular, it is more likely that beliefs about Russia and China are more complicated than you would like to believe about what you imagine is your base. Again, you can't prove it, but I leave my concessions above for you to consider.

As for "it is not a logical opinion." Ridiculous. You state this without any supporting evidence, but the one lacking logic here is you. You disregard history and blame everything on an invisible body of Jews, which I doubt you could successfully identify. Ladislaus has pointed out that modern Jews show division and have differing opinions which lead to conflicts even within Israel. I do believe in the historical Communist conspiracy with Jews behind it, but it does become illogical and nonsensical without the glue of Marxism to hold it together in light of the past century. More conspiracy theorism.

That's why you get a lot of flack here, even though a few here do agree with you.

"A few." You don't know how many people agree with me, in whole or in part. A larger part of the readership here does not have an account and an event smaller number of the readership have an account and actively post. The loudest posters make their positions known, but what the readership at large believes is not known. We can expect that they must hold to the positions of Bp. Williamson, or at least recognize him to some degree while disagreeing on some points or belonging to an entirely different position altogether.

You might also be surprised to know that a sizable number don't follow politics. It's not a solid block of pro-Russia vs anti Russia, but the greater part are apathetic.

We are Traditional Catholics, not mindless zombies who go along with the mainstream media. That's something that you refuse to address.

This is pretty funny. You don't represent all Traditional Catholics, even within the SSPX Resistance. Anti-Communism is not associated with the mainstream media, because decades ago they rejected Golitsyn and chose to promote the liberalization of Perestroika as legitimate. You refuse to address that the Democrats have been in bed with Communists and Russia for decades, and with many of their careers started with the help of Communists, yet now we are meant to believe that the Obama about-face on Russia is legitimate. Where is the logic there?

In fact, the pro-Russian faction on the forum is very intolerant of dissenting beliefs.

No, we're just intolerant of mindless propaganda, falsehoods, inexplicable praise for the corrupted West, and so forth.  Some of what you propose is so absurd that it's no wonder that you're considered a shill.  You show zero objectivity in your analysis.