95% truth, 5% poison.
He is saying the revolution came AFTER Vll and not because of it.....
I think he is trying to counter Vigano and reel in the "moderate" Trads
so they don't leave...

Bishop Schneider Explains The Deepest Crisis Of The Catholic Church Today (rumble.com)

https://rumble.com/vnheat-bishop-schneider-explains-the-deepest-crisis-of-the-catholic-church-today.html?mref=dfum5&mc=cpj1y

https://rumble.com/vnheat-bishop-schneider-explains-the-deepest-crisis-of-the-catholic-church-today.html

I keep hoping he will catch up to Vigano, but news like this frustrates my hopes.

Pray for him, that he wakes up soon.

Bishop Schneider is on the same page as +Fellay.

95% truth, 5% poison.

He is saying the revolution came AFTER Vll and not because of it.....

Yeah, at this point, anyone who argues the above is either a grossly, willfully, uneducated idiot, or a liar.

Yeah, at this point, anyone who argues the above is either a grossly, willfully, uneducated idiot, or a liar.

Not necessarily.  There's a school of thought which holds (rightly IMO) that an Ecuмenical Council is guided by the Holy Spirit and therefore cannot be harmful to the Church.  So it's his attempt to reconcile the obvious wreckage in the wake of Vatican II, arguing that blaming Vatican II is a case of post hoc, propter hoc fallacy.  +Vigano has managed to cut through that and realizes how V2 is directly responsible.  This is actually the same major premise that's held by sedevacantists, that a legitimate Ecuмenical Council cannot cause this kind of damage to the Church.

Not necessarily.  There's a school of thought which holds (rightly IMO) that an Ecuмenical Council is guided by the Holy Spirit and therefore cannot be harmful to the Church.

I'm not talking about this aspect of the revolution, but the revolution as a whole.

He is saying the revolution came AFTER Vll and not because of it.....

I'm talking about the historically, factual revolution that started in the 1700/1800s (illuminati), ramped up in the late 1800s so that Bl Pope Pius IX was imprisoned in the Vatican, and then was defeated (temporarily) and exposed by Pope St Pius X in the early 1900s, and confirmed by Our Lady at Fatima.

At this point, with someone as educated at +Schneider, to say that the revolution in the church *started* post V2 is just to ignore history, facts and reality.  It's like saying that the north-south didn't start hating each other until *after* the cινιℓ ωαr started.  It makes no sense.  Ideas/emotion always come before action.  Therefore, the revolution idea/planning started BEFORE the revolution event (i.e. V2). 

Even if you argue that the 1800s revolution is unconnected with V2, to argue that there was no build-up, planning, or conspiracy in the decade(s) prior to the 60s is just laughable.  +Schneider is simply (like the new-sspx) denying that a global conspiracy exists, to keep the sheeple calm and pacified.  

Nostra Aetate , Gaudium et Spes, Lumen Gentium...really?

Absolutely.  They come up with various "hermeneutic of continuity" explanations for what the problematic sections "REALLY" mean.  It's a huge stretch, but I'm just explaining their thinking on the subject.  +Schneider admitted that a few passages would have to be "amended" but then applies the "hermeneutic" to the rest.  That's precisely what +Vigano took exception to in his first ground-breaking letter.

“Baptist Churches are often raided. This is due to the church members gathering without registering themselves, a requirement of the country. Anyone who does not register risk being raided by the police. However not only those that violate the law are treated harshly.^[8]

On May 2, 2017, a court in the capital of Astana, Kazakhstan, sentenced a 61-year-old husband and father of three sons to a five-year prison sentence for performing peaceful Bible education work. Teymur Akhmedov, is a member of Jehovah's Witnesses. The court called his preaching and teaching efforts “inciting religious discord” and “advocating [religious] superiority.” In addition, the judge also imposed a three-year ban on Mr. Akhmedov’s participation in Bible education activities. Mr Akhmedov's medical issues were not considered, as he requires treatment for a bleeding tumor and has been denied the
medical attention that he requires.^{[9]” “}




It is a mostly moslem country where it is against the law to go out and spread the gospel of Jesus Christ.