Catholic Info
Traditional Catholic Faith => The Library => Topic started by: Mark 79 on December 06, 2024, 06:01:47 PM
-
Equating the ѕуηαgσgυє of Satan, тαℓмυdic Jєωs, and even secular Jєωs with "all Israel" is one of the most pernicious heresies to invade the Church. Roy Schoeman, his Salvation is from the Jєωs book and website (one and the same website to which PV directed us!!!) is arguably the most pernicious and successfully subversive marrano alive today. In every venue Schoeman pushes his heretical misinterpretations of "all Israel." His heretical claims have been thoroughly debunked. I have attached three such exposés below.
-
:facepalm: I don’t even know who this Roy guy is. But his site has numerous quotes from the Church Fathers.
Read the quotes, ignore Roy’s commentary. It’s how grownups approach research.
-
Roy Schoeman, his Salvation is from the Jєωs book and website (one and the same website to which PV directed us!!!) is arguably the most pernicious and successfully subversive marrano alive today.
Thanks for posting about this. People need to be warned.
-
:facepalm: I don’t even know who this Roy guy is. But his site has numerous quotes from the Church Fathers.
Read the quotes, ignore Roy’s commentary. It’s how grownups approach research.
He was a Havard Business professor when he had an apparition from Our Lady and became a Catholic. Very fervent but misguided in this matter, it can happen... His conferences are on YouTube, the story of his conversion is quite funny, he has a good sense of humour.
-
:facepalm: I don’t even know who this Roy guy is.
Then find out before giving your opinion. Read the attachments.
-
:facepalm: I don’t even know who this Roy guy is. But his site has numerous quotes from the Church Fathers.
Read the quotes, ignore Roy’s commentary. It’s how grownups approach research.
Do you understand that The Library section is NOT for discussion? According to Matthew's rules, discussion is relegated to other threads, as you and I are doing right now.
Further, at this time, you did not download even one of Sungenis's three criticisms. You insist I read you references (as I did), but hypocritically you have not read the references I provided.
Sorry, I addressed the content in an attempted follow-up post, but when it "timed out" I lost all the work. So, here is the short version…
Yeah, the marrano offered dozens of quotes. All but one of the quotes generalized ambiguously, and danced around the "all Israel" problem I mentioned [see *** below]. Interested readers can confirm that for themselves by going to your link.
The only quote that Schoeman offered stating "universally" was a misattributed quote of St. [Thomas] Aquinas. Because he cited a secondary source, I had to dig to find the original source and as I read the original source it was a hypothetical consideration from St. Thomas, not a conclusion.
If you want to chase that down, read the "St. Thomas Aquinas" chapter in Sungenis's debunking of Fr. Mawdsley [attached to this post for download].
As I expected, I wasted almost 2 hours chasing down 1 misattributed quote that was a hypothetical and wasn't even dispositive… and has some serious grammar problems. So (((stereotypical))).
There is nothing solid in the page you offered that unequivocally states there will be no exceptions on The Last Day.
So, I am going with what His Excellency wrote to me, "exceptions" precisely the same as I have been catechized throughout my Catholic education and adult life.
***
Quote from: Mark 79 12/6/2024, 4:40:21 PM
…Just as today's mostly-European тαℓмυdic Jєωs arrogate to themselves the carnal lineage of Abraham (as Christ threw in their faces in Matthew 3:9), they insist that the ѕуηαgσgυє of Satan's project in the Holy Land is "Israel."
That is NOT the Catholic understanding; that is the "Jєωιѕн understanding" …. It is a satanic lie.
The Catholic understanding, the Truth, is (1) that practicing Catholics are now the only true Jєωs today,(2) Catholics are the only Chosen People of God today, and (3) the one Church that Christ founded in Matthew 16:18 is today's only true Israel.
In only that Catholic sense will "all Israel" be saved.
Equating the ѕуηαgσgυє of Satan, тαℓмυdic Jєωs, and even secular Jєωs with "all Israel" is one of the most pernicious heresies to invade the Church. Roy Schoeman, his Salvation is from the Jєωs book and website (one and the same website to which PV directed us!!!) is arguably the most pernicious and successfully subversive marrano alive today. In every venue Schoeman pushes his heretical misinterpretations of "all Israel." His heretical claims have been thoroughly debunked. I have attached three such exposés [attached to my original post above].
There is a remnant of Jєωs who will be saved, some on The Last Day and some before The Last Day.
Now please be so kind as to respect Matthew's Library Rules. Take it to the other thread.
-
The library is for posting information. You included a negative comment about me and which was unnecessary and also against the rules.
-
I said: "…and [Schoeman's] website (one and the same website to which PV directed us!!!)"
You now think it is "negative" to note that you directed us to Schoeman's website.
If you didn't think Schoeman's site was a "positive," why did you direct readers there?
If you only belatedly discovered that Schoeman's site is "negative," why didn't you carefully check it before referring readers there?
A more personal "negative" here is that you directed readers to Schoeman's "negative" site either knowingly or carelessly.
Especially when arguing about tendentious issues, why in the world wouldn't you check out your source first???
-
He was a Havard Business professor when he had an apparition from Our Lady and became a Catholic. Very fervent but misguided in this matter, it can happen... His conferences are on YouTube, the story of his conversion is quite funny, he has a good sense of humour.
Roy's nickname is "The miraculous Marrano".