Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO
0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.
...So, I've actually never heard directly his condemnation of "Sound of Music". If someone has audio/video, I'd love to hear it. Boy this roiled Trads everywhere more than even his saying women shouldn't wear pants or go to university or hold down jobs. In fact, he would have caused less turmoil, controversy, and "scandal" had he come out as a full-blown foaming-at-the-mouth dogmatic SV who held that it's mortal sin to attend una cuм Masses, became "Feeneyite", and moved in with the Dimond Brothers. I imagine it was because he felt it was too sappy and emotional. I see his perspective, since the treatment of her vocation (or lack thereof) was not handled very well, making it seem like various emotions tugging her in different directions. But he should have appreciated your comment because he acknowledges that Beethoven is a Romantic and admits that he's his "guilty pleasure."
I found the most complete treatment in the link below. It's actually quite good and spot on, IMO ... though perhaps he's taking a bit of dumb musical entertainment a little too seriously. All these types of movies are meant to be "feel good" types.https://williamsonletters.blogspot.com/2009/02/problem-with-sound-of-music.htmlI agree with all his points ... except that I don't think that this movie has influenced me or many other people a lick in terms of our attitudes toward real life. I liken it to violent video games where you might go blowing away electronic people but it doesn't mean you'd ever hurt someone in real life. I have trouble smashing a fly if I don't have to but have no problems with a video game blowing away a thousand bad guys ... since I can tell the difference between that and reality ... though I haven't played video games much in 40+ years. But maybe done people can't ... don't know. Perhaps he mentioned might be influenced by it ... whereas men are not.Girl do relish attention and making everything about "me" ... and being that Barbie prices who, though born a pauper, truly deserves and has a right a handsome prince that puts her on some pedestal to worship.It does also present her married state as almost superior, where her vibrant joy and vitality is simply incompatible with the constraints of the dour convent life. That place is only for people that don't have her joy of life.
Because children are innocent, and adults quickly corrupt into worse than garbage.
I think pretty much the same now as I did at age seven.
Influenced in real life by the Sound of Music because I’m female? Really? I saw the movie as a seven year old child, and I remember thinking that Maria should have gone back to the convent to remain. That’s that what I would have done.
I didn't say all were, but many/most are women are influenced by such things, as they are influenced by all the princess stories in which they obviously imagine themselves in the starring role ... leading to a sense of entitlement. Your reaction that she should have returned to the convent is, let's just say, probably in the minority for women. Even in my perspective, she was not a fit for convent ... though not because she was superior to it, as the movie implies, but not cut out for it in general, due to being too whimsical, lacking in seriousness or any faith that I could see during the movie.