If I remember correctly, Fr Hesse said something about Thomas Aquinas saying that first we believe in something, then we explain it.
It's really easy to explain flat earth when you already believe it. Perhaps that is why so many people of so many different views (protestants, Muslims, liberals, evolutionists, and honestly even Catholics and conservatives) are so stubborn in their opinions/beliefs even against contradictory evidence.
Credo ut intelligam.What you're missing is that no current FE started off by believing that earth is flat. We've all been indoctrinated into globe earth. It took me personally 2 years of going through the evidence and arguments from both sides, before I became an FE, rather reluctantly. Many of the current FEs actually set out to debunk it and then became convinced they had been wrong.
My personal process:
1) I think it's ridiculous, but because I deliberately keep an open mind, I'll have a look (based on posts that the FEs made in that sub-forum). I can't just dismiss it and write it off while knowing very little about the case they're trying to make.
2) Hmmm, this isn't as ridiculous as I thought. There may be SOMEthing to it. Let me dig some more.
3) Wow, I'm starting to think they might be right. I can't believe this.
4) I lean FE (as I posted in the sub-forum)
5) I'm completely convinced.
This process took two years, and the one thing you have to already know to be able to successfully navigate through this is that the government lies like it's going out of style. I already knew that the moon landings were a complete hoax, so it wasn't that much of a stretch to believe that NASA might be lying about other stuff as well.