CathInfo.com

Or maybe it just proves how magnificent God's creation is. Working perfectly and everything in order.

Yes, His creation is perfect.






Just one question about this model though...





Where is the firmament?





Firmament is in the Bible 23 times.  I don't see it here:





Where is it??



Is the Bible wrong?  23 times?

1.The Bible never said the firmament is visible or solid.

Thank you, Mr. Protestant, for your opinion, but Catholics understand Sacred Scripture based on the unanimous interpretation of the Church Fathers, and they unanimously believed in a physical firmament that kept physical waters above the sky from flooding the earth.

1.The Bible never said the firmament is visible or solid.

And God said: Let there be a firmament made amidst the waters: and let it divide the waters from the waters. - Genesis 1:6
A firmament: Strabus and Bede teach that there is an eternal heaven, because the firmament, which they take to mean the sidereal heaven, is said to have been made, not in the beginning, but on the second day: whereas the reason given by Basil is that otherwise God would seem to have made darkness His first work. Augustine says (Gen. ad lit. i, 9) that the heaven of the second day is the corporeal heaven. According to Damascene (De Fide Orth. ii) the firmament made on the second day is the starry heaven. Chrysostom understood that the heaven in 1:1 is the same heaven of the second day.

Sidereal/physical Heaven was to distinguish that Heaven from the Heaven in which God dwells (which is immaterial / spiritual ... although there are mansions prepared there for those who will dwell in Heaven with physical bodies, e.g. Our Lord, Our Lady, likely St. Joseph, and eventually all the human elect).  So you're begging the question pretending that this "sideral heaven" implies the vastness of space that holds the stars.  That's not how the Church Fathers understood it.  They believed it to be solid and that the stars (smaller lights) were in it.  There were debates among the Fathers about 1) what it was made of and 2) whether the sun, moon, stars move within it vs. whether they are fixed in the firmament and the firmament as a whole moves around the earth.  And the entire debate / argument / dispute had to do with the question of how is it possible for physical objects to move within another physical object (the firmament).  Those who did not believe it possible held that the firmament itself (being solid) moved around the earth.  Others believed that the firmament was made of some kind of quasi-solid substance (similar to some kind of hard plasma) where the solid matter could be displaced the same way as happens when objects move through water, and yet it was more solid than water so that water could not pass through it (since it kept actual physical waters out from atmosphere and from flooding the earth).

So because you believe that the stars are these giant suns, you falsely equate mention of "sidereal heaven" with some vast space.  To repeat, the Jєωs and the Church Fathers believed in THREE heavens.  First Heaven was Air (where birds fly, etc.), Second Heaven was the Firmament (in which the Sun, Moon, and Stars are), and the Third Heaven was where God and the angels are.  That second was also called the Sidereal/Physical Heaven and the mention of Sideral/Physical Heaven does not mean what you try to pretend it does.  So their cosmology involved the earth, with the First Heaven (sky, atmosphere) above it, and this First Heaven was made possible by this Firmament (the second Heaven or sidereal / physical heaven) keeping out these waters.  Then outside the waters, you had the Heaven of God (or Third Heaven).  They believed there was a gate in the Second Heaven (sideral/physical) that opened into some tunnel that passed through the waters and ultimately out into the Heaven of God (Third Heaven).  This is what St. Paul meant when he was describing someone (likely himself) who was taken up into the "Third Heaven" that were beyond the wildest human imagination.