Author Topic: Aristotles unfortunate errors (Read 1360 times)

Predestination2 · « **on:** May 11, 2025, 06:31:08 AM »

Aristotle was taught under Plato, by Plato I mean the Plato who believed in shared wives and was himself taught by the wicked sodomite Socrates who believed that man was a featherless chicken!, this Plato was the first after the Pythagoreans to suggest the lobotomised at best and devil worshipping at worst laughing stock called a spherical earth. Plato in his younger days supported sodomy and (((mccarrick behaviours))), but thankfully due to Xenophon was steered away from these wicked ideas to a more human understanding in his book laws where he outright condemned these practices once and for all. It it a great surprise that Aristotle managed to get so many things correct in view of his mentor but he did not manage to free from all the errors of his mentor Plato.

The first great error of Aristotle was a spherical earth

The second great error of Aristotle was an earth which was “170” times smaller than the sun. And through this we can tell that Aristotle was sadly influenced by the evil satanist Pythagoras (who from observation of the disgusting things he taught, almost certainly was raised by mentored by or descended from Jews (Edomites NOT isaelites)).

The third great error of Aristotle was his idea that a man ought to enter into marriage at 37. This is stupid for multiple reasons. Firstly this error from the past contradicts the current teachings of the church (which I know did not exist in Aristotles time because he was a gentile from the Old Testament yeah yeah that’s past the point). Secondly if people took this foolish idea seriously they would surely end up in hell. To wait 30 years from when they gain the age of reason without committing solitary sins or fornication would be practically impossible for many men. This error is not only egregious but is bordering on tempting God.

I also remember hearing from Bishop Sanborn that Aristotle and the peripatetics taught one very egregious moral error but I cannot recall what it was.

This should not be dismissed as off topic as many of my posts and comments have been as this is a post not a comment.

Predestination2 · « **Reply #1 on:** May 11, 2025, 06:35:19 AM »

No wonder St. Thomas was given such a hard time for synthesising Aristotle. Also according to ai overview (which gave no source and is usually confidently wring which is why I didn’t put it in the top post), Aristotle never explicitly condemned premarital fornication, I believe that may have been the error which Bishop Sanborn pointed out about Aristotle. Though I do not know.

AnthonyPadua · « **Reply #2 on:** May 11, 2025, 07:07:22 AM »

Quote from: Predestination2 on May 11, 2025, 06:31:08 AM

The third great error of Aristotle was his idea that a man ought to enter into marriage at 37. This is stupid for multiple reasons. Firstly this error from the past contradicts the current teachings of the church (which I know did not exist in Aristotles time because he was a gentile from the Old Testament yeah yeah that’s past the point). Secondly if people took this foolish idea seriously they would surely end up in hell. To wait 30 years from when they gain the age of reason without committing solitary sins or fornication would be practically impossible for many men. This error is not only egregious but is bordering on tempting God.

Based on fertility men hit their peak in the early to mid 20s. Same with physical attractiveness. (For the majority).

OABrownson1876 · « **Reply #3 on:** May 11, 2025, 08:10:10 PM »

Quote from: Predestination2 on May 11, 2025, 06:31:08 AM

Aristotle was taught under Plato, by Plato I mean the Plato who believed in shared wives and was himself taught by the wicked sodomite Socrates who believed that man was a featherless chicken!, this Plato was the first after the Pythagoreans to suggest the lobotomised at best and devil worshipping at worst laughing stock called a spherical earth. Plato in his younger days supported sodomy and (((mccarrick behaviours))), but thankfully due to Xenophon was steered away from these wicked ideas to a more human understanding in his book laws where he outright condemned these practices once and for all. It it a great surprise that Aristotle managed to get so many things correct in view of his mentor but he did not manage to free from all the errors of his mentor Plato.

The first great error of Aristotle was a spherical earth

The second great error of Aristotle was an earth which was “170” times smaller than the sun. And through this we can tell that Aristotle was sadly influenced by the evil satanist Pythagoras (who from observation of the disgusting things he taught, almost certainly was raised by mentored by or descended from Jews (Edomites NOT isaelites)).

The third great error of Aristotle was his idea that a man ought to enter into marriage at 37. This is stupid for multiple reasons. Firstly this error from the past contradicts the current teachings of the church (which I know did not exist in Aristotles time because he was a gentile from the Old Testament yeah yeah that’s past the point). Secondly if people took this foolish idea seriously they would surely end up in hell. To wait 30 years from when they gain the age of reason without committing solitary sins or fornication would be practically impossible for many men. This error is not only egregious but is bordering on tempting God.

I also remember hearing from Bishop Sanborn that Aristotle and the peripatetics taught one very egregious moral error but I cannot recall what it was.

This should not be dismissed as off topic as many of my posts and comments have been as this is a post not a comment.

I take issue with your castigation of Socrates as a "wicked sodomite." St. Justin Martyr practically puts Socrates in heaven if you read the Dialogue with Trypho. In the famous work, The Symposium, Socrates arises at table and the handsome Alcibiades says of him, "Socrates removed his coat and never was there a more beautiful man." This is irony because we know that Socrates was not handsome. The Greek used by Alcibiades was silenoi, which were little statuettes, which, when opened, had little golden trinkets inside the chest. Alcibiades got Roxanne pregnant, and her father the king, was going to lop off his head for getting his daughter pregnant. Socrates interposed with the king and had the life of Alcibiades spared. Socrates told the king, "Spare his life because I believe that there is some goodness in him." I believe that part of the reason Socrates was murdered in a bogus trial (read the book, Trial of Socrates) is because he was calling out the immorality in Athens.

Predestination2 · « **Reply #4 on:** May 11, 2025, 10:01:09 PM »

Quote from: OABrownson1876 on May 11, 2025, 08:10:10 PM

I take issue with your castigation of Socrates as a "wicked sodomite." St. Justin Martyr practically puts Socrates in heaven if you read the Dialogue with Trypho. In the famous work, The Symposium, Socrates arises at table and the handsome Alcibiades says of him, "Socrates removed his coat and never was there a more beautiful man." This is irony because we know that Socrates was not handsome. The Greek used by Alcibiades was silenoi, which were little statuettes, which, when opened, had little golden trinkets inside the chest. Alcibiades got Roxanne pregnant, and her father the king, was going to lop off his head for getting his daughter pregnant. Socrates interposed with the king and had the life of Alcibiades spared. Socrates told the king, "Spare his life because I believe that there is some goodness in him." I believe that part of the reason Socrates was murdered in a bogus trial (read the book, Trial of Socrates) is because he was calling out the immorality in Athens.

Well then I repent

Author Topic: Aristotles unfortunate errors (Read 1360 times)

Predestination2

Aristotles unfortunate errors

Predestination2

Re: Aristotles unfortunate errors

AnthonyPadua

Re: Aristotles unfortunate errors

OABrownson1876

Re: Aristotles unfortunate errors

Predestination2

Re: Aristotles unfortunate errors