Speaking of researching Cosmas, happenby apparently does not realize that scholars who have studied his writings identify many different ideas characteristic of Nestorianism. It is generally recognized that Cosmas was either a Nestorian himself or, at best, heavily influenced by the Nestorian heresy. Even the Catholic Encyclopedia article on him mentions this.
Rather than holding him up as an example of orthodox Christian thought and spokesman for the Fathers, as happenby does, we ought to view everything he writes with suspicion. He is tainted with heterodoxy.
Many of us know she's been malicious, but this is just rotten. Had she read the book, or done research to include whether or not this calumny against Cosmas had any truth to it before she cast aspersions she would have saved herself more embarrassment. Both philosophically and cartographically, Cosmas' ideas were strictly dictated by his literal interpretation of the Bible; and for his incredible humility and genius, he was highly esteemed in Christendom. Cosmas'
Christian Topography has been preserved in two copies: one a parchment manuscript of the 10th century belonging to the Laurentian Library in Florence, containing the whole work except the last leaf; the other, a very fine manuscript of the 8th or 9th century, belonging to the Vatican Library. The
Christian Topography contains, in all probability, the oldest Christian maps known. His writings were highly revered in Christendom for 700 years. No doubt Cosmas's comparison of the first tabernacle to the earth contributed to hundreds of years of Church architecture highlighting high altars with their star-representing candlesticks, enormous granite pillars, and vaulted domes with frescoes of angels and saints in heaven, above. Cosmas' description of the liturgy in relation to the form of the earth is nothing less than inspired, and its a crime more Catholics aren't aware of the typology to help them understand the Mass in relation to the Old Testament as well as the fulfillment in the New Testament. The accusation of Cosmas being a Nestorian came from the fact that poor Cosmas had Nestorian friends. Such a thing cannot prove one is a heretic. Another piece of information sheds more light. Nestorians refused to recognize Mary as the mother of God, yet Cosmas
glowingly referred to Our Lady as
"Theotokos", "Mother of God". So much for nice tries. This pathetic attempt to defame Cosmas exposes an intentional failure to examine more closely the facts, and the failure to examine the morons who, contradicting Cosmas, attempt to lie, cheat and steal in order to erase history, beat on God's messengers and lead people astray with false notions of creation. I say this is intentional because, without fail, this woman hails the religion of globalism to the point of worship, praises its high-priest scientists, sings off-key with her choir of anti-Catholic supporters who consistently get a pass from her, while everything Catholic is disparaged.
:heretic: