Congratulations
claudel, on being the first person on here discerning enough to see, or bold enough to denounce me for, my psuedointellectualism. Yes, everything I write on this forum is the fruit of
lazy, half-ripe thought; but in my defence we are in the
Teen Catholic Hangout subsection of an internet forum; and while that does not excuse me from my arrogance, it does somewhat make your aggressive tone seem superfluous.
Please tell me the names of a few books or essays by Adorno that you've read.
A single essay. That's all I needed to pigeonhole him as a neurotic Jєω. That, an the reputation of the Frankfurt School and its Marxism.
Can you tell me the relation, if any, between Theodor Adorno and Gabriele Adorno?
No I cannot, because I do not know whom the latter is.
Whence does your knowledge of Scientology stem? First-hand experience? Critical literature? Talk radio?
You know, hearsay.
Among how many enormous crowds of overly dressed buffoons have you sat whilst with sharpened teeth they waited to devour a pianist should he strike a wrong note? One? Two? Perhaps as many as three?
None, actually.
Have you ever listened, critically or otherwise, to Bruckner's Sixth or Ninth Symphony? By critically, I mean attentively.
I listened to the first few chords. That's all I needed to pigeonhole him as a neurotic modern composer.
Last but not least, what's wrong with pronouncing Mozart's name correctly?
Nothing; I was painting a picture of affected manners, one that seems to have rubbed you in the wrong way, unfortunately, and for that I apologize.
You do not really address my main point. My main point was that classical music, like nearly all of the culture that has come out of the last few centuries, is infected with a humanism that is antithetical to Catholicism. I do not think that your listening to Bruckner "critically, attentively" is anything to be proud of. I do not think Beethoven and Mozart have any importance, and I conveyed that meaning by saying that you could throw away their work for the sake of keeping an old folk song, for all I care. I think that the genius cult, a subsection of the humanity cult (humanism), that is popular even to this day is morally sickening. I think the humility of a Saint is more impressive than all the works of all the greatest Western composers, which is why I have such contempt for the culture of "music appreciation" and the worldly haughtiness that attends it.
However, I do need to humble myself and stop vainly pontificating on the internet. My education consists of scraps gleaned from sundry sources, and I am a pretentious know-it-all. When I was on this forum a month ago I made a resolution not to return until I had seen a change in myself, and that resolution has been broken. I need to retire from this place once more; the reason why I am here is to fritter away time, and it's disgraceful and irresponsible of me. I've talked about a lot of the things I dislike in this thread - like snobishness - and yet here I am guilty of the same thing that I accuse others of. That's hypocrisy. I'm doubleminded and that's why I'm here: I'm failing to make a decision and so decide to be apathetic instead. Thank you for the greatly needed reminder,
claudel. I keep ignoring all of the graces that God is offering me in order to feed my vanity in all sorts of ways. Please, forgive me my arrogance.