Catholic Info

Traditional Catholic Faith => Funny Stuff for Catholics => Topic started by: AnthonyPadua on October 15, 2023, 08:51:31 AM

Title: A.I Lord of the rings
Post by: AnthonyPadua on October 15, 2023, 08:51:31 AM
https://youtu.be/7HLCN_13onk?si=Lg7L1OOmR8cIWn1c

:laugh2:
Title: Re: A.I Lord of the rings
Post by: AnthonyPadua on October 15, 2023, 08:57:36 AM
https://youtu.be/7HLCN_13onk?si=Lg7L1OOmR8cIWn1c

:laugh2:
The first 2

https://youtu.be/4QAzmSy6MWk?si=gBd4CMYSeVfbxZZr

https://youtu.be/LuBqsmi3i2E?si=i0WPPDgoH_IkLkuj
Title: Re: A.I Lord of the rings
Post by: Matthew on October 15, 2023, 09:15:40 AM
Funny, but here's the thing --

We're laughing AT this "masterpiece" of AI, not WITH it.

This stupid AI text-to-video is like a 5 year old *earnestly doing their best* and they hold it up to you like, "Look Dad! I made Lord of the Rings! Isn't that cool?"

You know there's a difference between making a joke, passing it off like it's nothing and didn't take you weeks, and doing something with all your heart "for real" and it's supposed to be good -- but it's unintentionally hilarious it's so bad.

These videos are the latter.

Not saying the human creator was trying to make them serious -- he obviously realized quickly how funny it was, and is putting it forth as a joke. But not the AI! For the AI's part, it was honestly doing it's best to recreate Peter Jackson's famous trilogy.

See the limitations of computer software, something that will never actually *understand* things that your 5 year old understands? Zero faculty of reason. And this will never improve, not with 100,000 years. A machine will never have an immaterial soul, it will never trascend the physical realm, so it will never grasp immaterial things like CONCEPTS, IDEAS. It will never intellege (Latin, "read what is within") anything.
Title: Re: A.I Lord of the rings
Post by: AnthonyPadua on October 15, 2023, 06:23:35 PM
Funny, but here's the thing --

We're laughing AT this "masterpiece" of AI, not WITH it.

This stupid AI text-to-video is like a 5 year old *earnestly doing their best* and they hold it up to you like, "Look Dad! I made Lord of the Rings! Isn't that cool?"

You know there's a difference between making a joke, passing it off like it's nothing and didn't take you weeks, and doing something with all your heart "for real" and it's supposed to be good -- but it's unintentionally hilarious it's so bad.

These videos are the latter.

Not saying the human creator was trying to make them serious -- he obviously realized quickly how funny it was, and is putting it forth as a joke. But not the AI! For the AI's part, it was honestly doing it's best to recreate Peter Jackson's famous trilogy.

See the limitations of computer software, something that will never actually *understand* things that your 5 year old understands? Zero faculty of reason. And this will never improve, not with 100,000 years. A machine will never have an immaterial soul, it will never trascend the physical realm, so it will never grasp immaterial things like CONCEPTS, IDEAS. It will never intellege (Latin, "read what is within") anything.
Yes it was so 'bad' it was funny. Seeing them use phones and tanks and motorcycles...

I understand that a.i is a 'meme' and just a dumb computer with no brain.