CathInfo.com

It was rants exactly like his, however, that initially prompted me to look at the dreaded evil of sedevacantism.  And without the continual barrage of 'stay away!!!' I might have never left the Resistance. 

So for that I say, "Thank you, Kimmage and everyone else who shares your 'zeal'." 

Well ... that's because the grace of God was acting in you, and you were corresponding with it, but this kind of garbage, these fallacies that average people are unable to dispel since they're not educated, it and have a confusing impact on people and inculcate attitudes of Old Catholicism in people.

Similarly, one thing that attracted me to Tradtional Catholicism in the first place was where a couple Jesuits at my High School showed these videos mocking the Tridentine Mass, describing the priest as babbling unintelligibly with his back turned to the people ... but it involved showing a few minutes of footage from it.  Tuning out their commentary like the Charlie Brown Cartoon of "blah blah blah", I found myself mesmerized by the Mass.  So it backfired ... in my case.  But I'm sure that it propagandized many others against Traditionn.

Sadly, because of people like this, a significant percentage of today's R&R are very thinly-veiled smells-and-bells Old Catholics, many of whom may not even have the Catholic faith at this time, since they are rejecting the papacy as being the proximate rule of faith except for regarding the extremely rare solemn dogmatic definition.

So they still need to be exposed for who they are.

Are you a Cardinal? Bishop?

You know ... this guy is so retarded (due to heretical depravity) that he has no clue that he's condemning himself from his own mouth.  R&R make themsleves judges over the Pope and the Magisterium, where THEY decided if the Pope was right or wrong, inverting precisely the very role of the Magisterium, where the Magisterium is supposed to tell US whether our opinions are right or wrong.  So R&R put themselves above the Pope.

Now, both SV and R&R have concluded that the Conciliar Church is not Catholic, but SVs uphold the perennial Catholic teaching that the Pope and the Magisterium tell us what to believe and what to do.  We theorize, consistent with much Catholic prophecy and private revelation ... which is not inconsistent with the promises of Christ, that the reason this has happened is that "an enemy hath done this", that usurper non-popes have infiltrated what had been the visible institutions and office of the Church.  So the SV theory means to keep perennial Traditional Catholic ecclesiology intact, and this theory / solution does precisely that.  R&R on the other hand completely subvert Tradtion in pretending to uphold it ... just like Old Catholics do, as they cling to the traditional external but wreck the proximate rule of faith.  They throw nearly 2000 years of Catholic ecclesiology under the bus to save Prevost and Bergoglio, and the Apostate Satanic Lavender Mafia that have infiltrated the Church.  They blaspheme Holy Mother Church by telling everyone that she's become a Whore.

You know ... this guy is so retarded (due to heretical depravity) that he has no clue that he's condemning himself from his own mouth.  R&R make themsleves judges over the Pope and the Magisterium, where THEY decided if the Pope was right or wrong, inverting precisely the very role of the Magisterium, where the Magisterium is supposed to tell US whether our opinions are right or wrong.  So R&R put themselves above the Pope.

Now, both SV and R&R have concluded that the Conciliar Church is not Catholic, but SVs uphold the perennial Catholic teaching that the Pope and the Magisterium tell us what to believe and what to do.  We theorize, consistent with much Catholic prophecy and private revelation ... which is not inconsistent with the promises of Christ, that the reason this has happened is that "an enemy hath done this", that usurper non-popes have infiltrated what had been the visible institutions and office of the Church.  So the SV theory means to keep perennial Traditional Catholic ecclesiology intact, and this theory / solution does precisely that.  R&R on the other hand completely subvert Tradtion in pretending to uphold it ... just like Old Catholics do, as they cling to the traditional external but wreck the proximate rule of faith.  They throw nearly 2000 years of Catholic ecclesiology under the bus to save Prevost and Bergoglio, and the Apostate Satanic Lavender Mafia that have infiltrated the Church.  They blaspheme Holy Mother Church by telling everyone that she's become a Whore.

I really think its lost on you how hypocritical it is for you to complain to Matthew about how he tolerates me and my mocking Thuc, while at the same time you viciously attack everything Bishop Williamson stood for. The same Bishop Williamson that Matthew loves so much (as I do too).