Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Fr. Girouard: Saints talk about signs of being in the State of Grace.  (Read 2449 times)

0 Members and 16 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline StonewallCatho

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 101
  • Reputation: +280/-8
  • Gender: Male
POSTED WITH FR. GIROUARD'S PERMISSION.

Sermon of August 3rd, 2025.




SERMON SUMMARY FROM FR. GIROUARD:


INTRODUCTION:

With God's grace, we shall study some verses of today's epistle of St. Paul to the Romans, Chapter 8. The great Apostle reminds us that we are not debtors to the flesh, but rather debtors to Christ and the Holy Ghost. He shows us what we need to do if we want to obtain the inheritance promised us. It is a question of eternal Life or Death! So we can ask ourselves: Am I truly in the State of Grace? Are my sins truly forgiven? Am I doing the right thing? (Remember: To feel no guilt doesn't mean we are not guilty). Fortunately, we can obtain a degree of certainty about it.


1- ST. BERNARD GIVES US THREE SIGNS OF BEING IN THE STATE OF GRACE.

A) We recall the story of the paralytic forgiven and healed by Our Lord. "Stand up! Pick up your stretcher, and walk!"

B) St. Bernard, on the spiritual meaning of this story, shows us three signs of the remission of our sins:

     a-To  aspire to supernatural things, and have a supernatural outlook on everything.

     b-To rule over all the inclinations of nature by mortification.

     c- To leave the past behind, and move towards our true Home: Heaven! We must always make progress. We are not on a cruise ship, but on a Battleship!


2- OUR NATURE CANNOT BE MORTIFIED WITHOUT THE GREATEST PAINS!

A) Verses 12 and 13 of today's epistle.

B) Mortification is so difficult, because the ennemy is within: The "Flesh" is our "Old Man"! We must battle against our bad inclinations of body and soul.

C) We must mortify ourselves for supernatural motives.

D) Great quote from Cornelius A Lapide: The immense pain we have to endure if we truly endeavour to rule our Nature.


3- FORTUNATELY, THE HOLY GHOST MAKES UP FOR WHAT WE LACK IN STRENGTH.

A) Verse 14 of today's Epistle.

B) Quote from St. Augustine: This help from the Holy Ghost is a sign that we are in the State of Grace!

C) Example of Samson in the Book of Judges: "The Spirit of God rushed into him."


4- BUT THESE THREE SIGNS GIVE US NO ABSOLUTE CERTITUDE OF THE REMISSION OF OUR SINS.

A) Only a Moral Certitude.

B) Quote from St Gregory to his spiritual dirigée Gregoria: We need tears of contrition.

C) Acts of Mortification can be like such tears, if done for supernatural motives.

D) Fear for our salvation is much better than security.


CONCLUSION:

If we want to have a moral  certainty that our sins are forgiven, and therefore that we are in the State of Grace, we must follow the advices we have received from Saints Bernard, Augustine, Gregory, and the great Cornelius A Lapide: 1-Be Supernatural in all things; 2-Pray the Holy Ghost to help you truly put to death your "Old Man"; 3-Combat with vigor against error and sins, and aim to make progress in sanctification. Our greatest ally to obtain the help of the Holy Ghost, is Our Lady, who is the Spouse of the Holy Ghost. She is the Seat of Wisdom (Holy Ghost). Let us pray her under this beautiful title, and she will come to our aid!


VIDEO LINK:   https://iframe.mediadelivery.net/play/79118/f3489aef-0c1f-4553-839d-d0a2b8a0f4fe




Offline Colt

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 7
  • Reputation: +0/-9
  • Gender: Male
Re: Fr. Girouard: Saints talk about signs of being in the State of Grace.
« Reply #1 on: August 04, 2025, 08:56:59 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!5
  • Quote from: StonewallCatho 2025-08-04, 4:39:47 PM
    POSTED WITH FR. GIROUARD'S PERMISSION.

    Sermon of August 3rd, 2025.




    SERMON SUMMARY FROM FR. GIROUARD:



    INTRODUCTION:


    With God's grace, we shall study some verses of today's epistle of St. Paul to the Romans, Chapter 8. The great Apostle reminds us that we are not debtors to the flesh, but rather debtors to Christ and the Holy Ghost. He shows us what we need to do if we want to obtain the inheritance promised us. It is a question of eternal Life or Death! So we can ask ourselves: Am I truly in the State of Grace? Are my sins truly forgiven? Am I doing the right thing? (Remember: To feel no guilt doesn't mean we are not guilty). Fortunately, we can obtain a degree of certainty about it.



    1- ST. BERNARD GIVES US THREE SIGNS OF BEING IN THE STATE OF GRACE.


    A) We recall the story of the paralytic forgiven and healed by Our Lord. "Stand up! Pick up your stretcher, and walk!"


    B) St. Bernard, on the spiritual meaning of this story, shows us three signs of the remission of our sins:


        a-To  aspire to supernatural things, and have a supernatural outlook on everything.


        b-To rule over all the inclinations of nature by mortification.


        c- To leave the past behind, and move towards our true Home: Heaven! We must always make progress. We are not on a cruise ship, but on a Battleship!



    2- OUR NATURE CANNOT BE MORTIFIED WITHOUT THE GREATEST PAINS!


    A) Verses 12 and 13 of today's epistle.


    B) Mortification is so difficult, because the ennemy is within: The "Flesh" is our "Old Man"! We must battle against our bad inclinations of body and soul.


    C) We must mortify ourselves for supernatural motives.


    D) Great quote from Cornelius A Lapide: The immense pain we have to endure if we truly endeavour to rule our Nature.



    3- FORTUNATELY, THE HOLY GHOST MAKES UP FOR WHAT WE LACK IN STRENGTH.


    A) Verse 14 of today's Epistle.


    B) Quote from St. Augustine: This help from the Holy Ghost is a sign that we are in the State of Grace!


    C) Example of Samson in the Book of Judges: "The Spirit of God rushed into him."



    4- BUT THESE THREE SIGNS GIVE US NO ABSOLUTE CERTITUDE OF THE REMISSION OF OUR SINS.


    A) Only a Moral Certitude.


    B) Quote from St Gregory to his spiritual dirigée Gregoria: We need tears of contrition.


    C) Acts of Mortification can be like such tears, if done for supernatural motives.


    D) Fear for our salvation is much better than security.



    CONCLUSION:


    If we want to have a moral  certainty that our sins are forgiven, and therefore that we are in the State of Grace, we must follow the advices we have received from Saints Bernard, Augustine, Gregory, and the great Cornelius A Lapide: 1-Be Supernatural in all things; 2-Pray the Holy Ghost to help you truly put to death your "Old Man"; 3-Combat with vigor against error and sins, and aim to make progress in sanctification. Our greatest ally to obtain the help of the Holy Ghost, is Our Lady, who is the Spouse of the Holy Ghost. She is the Seat of Wisdom (Holy Ghost). Let us pray her under this beautiful title, and she will come to our aid!



    VIDEO LINK:  https://iframe.mediadelivery.net/play/79118/f3489aef-0c1f-4553-839d-d0a2b8a0f4fe
    Father, your sermon was moving. It was structured with grace, filled with the wisdom of the saints, and clearly aimed at sanctifying souls. But with all reverence and sorrow, I beg you. This is not enough.

    These are not ordinary times. The Church is eclipsed. Vatican II, the New Mass, and the new religion are deceiving millions and taking souls to hell. The wolves are no longer at the gate. They wear the mitre. And when sermons speak only of interior struggle without naming the war around us, the faithful are left unarmed.

    This homily could have been delivered in a Fraternity parish or even a well-meaning Novus Ordo chapel. But Father, we remember your voice when it thundered with clarity. You once warned us of the apostasy. You once named the enemy. You once stood where few dared to stand.

    Today, that silence is more dangerous than ever. The faithful are not looking for soft encouragement. They are looking for the trumpet to give a clear sound. Not just to pray, but to fight. Not just to be holy, but to reject error. Not just to mortify the flesh, but to resist the conciliar betrayal.

    If you do not speak, who will? If even the priests who once stood firm now preach like the reconciled, where shall the sheep go?

    We do not need safe sermons. We need fearless ones. You once knew that. I pray you will remember it again.




    Offline Miseremini

    • Hero Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 4574
    • Reputation: +3641/-312
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Fr. Girouard: Saints talk about signs of being in the State of Grace.
    « Reply #2 on: August 04, 2025, 09:34:24 PM »
  • Thanks!2
  • No Thanks!1
  • Father, your sermon was moving. It was structured with grace, filled with the wisdom of the saints, and clearly aimed at sanctifying souls.
    Your post should have stopped there.
    You're obviously not on Father's mailing list or you'd realize how disrespectful and INCORRECT the rest of your post was.  Father has never been hesitant to bluntly inform, warn, and steer his flock through the present mire we find ourselves in today.
    You owe him an apology.
    "Let God arise, and let His enemies be scattered: and them that hate Him flee from before His Holy Face"  Psalm 67:2[/b]


    Offline Colt

    • Newbie
    • *
    • Posts: 7
    • Reputation: +0/-9
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Fr. Girouard: Saints talk about signs of being in the State of Grace.
    « Reply #3 on: August 04, 2025, 09:41:13 PM »
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!2
  • Quote from: Miseremini 2025-08-04, 7:34:24 PM
    Your post should have stopped there.
    You're obviously not on Father's mailing list or you'd realize how disrespectful and INCORRECT the rest of your post was.  Father has never been hesitant to bluntly inform, warn, and steer his flock through the present mire we find ourselves in today.
    You owe him an apology.
    Thank you. If Father is still speaking boldly in private, I am truly glad. But this sermon, while spiritually rich, gave no warning about the crisis that is tearing the Church apart.

    When wolves are attacking in public, silence in public no matter how beautiful leaves souls exposed. The faithful are confused. Bishops are leading souls astray. The sacraments themselves are in question. In times like this, comfort is not enough. We need clarity.

    I meant no disrespect. Only sorrow. Many of us remember when Father’s voice was clear and unshakable. This sermon felt like a retreat when what we need is a call to arms.

    If that voice still lives in him, I pray he brings it back to the pulpit. The flock needs it more than ever.



    Offline StonewallCatho

    • Newbie
    • *
    • Posts: 101
    • Reputation: +280/-8
    • Gender: Male
    Re: Fr. Girouard: Saints talk about signs of being in the State of Grace.
    « Reply #4 on: August 04, 2025, 10:08:27 PM »
  • Thanks!2
  • No Thanks!0
  • Your post should have stopped there.
    You're obviously not on Father's mailing list or you'd realize how disrespectful and INCORRECT the rest of your post was.  Father has never been hesitant to bluntly inform, warn, and steer his flock through the present mire we find ourselves in today.
    You owe him an apology.
    I will tell Father to have a look at the replies. I don't think he will be troubled by Colt's reply. As you said rightly, Colt's reply shows he is not on Father's email list.

    Every sermon of the Fathers and Doctors of the Church was not preached against the heresies of their days. There are other subjects that are necessary to preach on as well, and they are necessary for the salvation of souls. 

    It is easy and more interesting to read/hear about the Crisis of the Church and of the Neo-SSPX, and about the End Times and other hot topics. It is more difficult for some people like Colt to focus on the war against their Old Man.


    Offline Miseremini

    • Hero Member
    • *****
    • Posts: 4574
    • Reputation: +3641/-312
    • Gender: Female
    Re: Fr. Girouard: Saints talk about signs of being in the State of Grace.
    « Reply #5 on: August 04, 2025, 11:50:23 PM »
  • Thanks!1
  • No Thanks!0
  • this sermon, while spiritually rich, gave no warning about the crisis that is tearing the Church apart.
    The people to whom Father addressed this sermon are well aware in detail of the crisis that is tearing the Church apart and are informed of every new infraction that comes along by Father.
    Their souls need the ammunition to fight, which Father also gives them.
    "Let God arise, and let His enemies be scattered: and them that hate Him flee from before His Holy Face"  Psalm 67:2[/b]


    Offline Gray2023

    • Supporter
    • ****
    • Posts: 3005
    • Reputation: +1683/-948
    • Gender: Female
  • Thanks!1
  • No Thanks!0
  • Yes a wonderful sermon.  It kind of reminds me of the instructions of flight attendants.  Put your oxygen mask on first before you help others who need your assistance. :pray::pray::pray:
    1 Corinthians: Chapter 13 "4 Charity is patient, is kind: charity envieth not, dealeth not perversely; is not puffed up; 5 Is not ambitious, seeketh not her own, is not provoked to anger, thinketh no evil;"

    Offline Matthew

    • Mod
    • *****
    • Posts: 32908
    • Reputation: +29188/-596
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • I would say the exact opposite. Priests like Fr. Pfeiffer are also problematic: they OBSESSES with "the fight" to the point they are constantly fighting, EVEN WITH THEIR FELLOW-PRIESTS WHOM THEY SHOULD BE ALLIES WITH.
    And they have been adversarial and "fighting" for so long, they forgot what they are even fighting for. They can't even remember the "basics" of how to live a Catholic life -- basic Ascetical & Mystical theology. Bitter zeal has become a way of life.

    We all admire the "fighters" who name names, speak truth to power, fight against whoever they have to, in pursuit of truth and righteousness. The modern-day heroes and martyrs.
    But once in a while you have to put down your sword and pick up your rosary, and in general foster a deep and real PRAYER LIFE.

    As someone above pointed out, these topics of basic Catholic life are EVERY BIT AS IMPORTANT as naming the Jew, criticizing the Pope/SSPX/etc. or any other "fighting" or controversial topic.

    You can't leave out these basic topics, just because there is a Crisis.

    Personally, I think priests like Fr. Pfeiffer are a sad collateral damage from the Crisis in the Church. Imagine forgetting how to just stop and be Catholic. Just stop and serve God, meditate on the life of Our Lord, the Blessed Virgin, enjoy a good Catholic hymn, enjoy the beauty of God's creation, offer praise to God -- you know, stop and "live". Especially doing things constructive (helping new converts, mentoring young Catholics, volunteering at a Trad chapel, etc.) We shouldn't lose sight of these positive things because we've been fighting a bitter fight for so long.

    It reminds me of a soldier who has been at war for 10 years and can barely remember what he was fighting for. He can no longer enjoy most of what he is "defending" in the war -- he has lost all taste for actual day-to-day life in the country he left to fight.

    Want to say "thank you"? 
    You can send me a gift from my Amazon wishlist!
    https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

    My accounts (Paypal, Venmo) have been (((shut down))) PM me for how to donate and keep the forum going.


    Offline Pax Vobis

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 12349
    • Reputation: +7847/-2433
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!3
  • No Thanks!0
  • Thank you. If Father is still speaking boldly in private, I am truly glad. But this sermon, while spiritually rich, gave no warning about the crisis that is tearing the Church apart.

    When wolves are attacking in public, silence in public no matter how beautiful leaves souls exposed. The faithful are confused. Bishops are leading souls astray. The sacraments themselves are in question. In times like this, comfort is not enough. We need clarity.

    I meant no disrespect. Only sorrow. Many of us remember when Father’s voice was clear and unshakable. This sermon felt like a retreat when what we need is a call to arms.

    If that voice still lives in him, I pray he brings it back to the pulpit. The flock needs it more than ever.
    :facepalm:  Look at the gospels as an example to how the Church gives VARIETY in teaching, from Sunday to Sunday.  Not every gospel is about hell.  Not every gospel is about Christ performing miracles. 

    Priests have been preaching about the crisis in the Church for 60 years.  There are a variety of other topics which are important.

    Offline Matthew

    • Mod
    • *****
    • Posts: 32908
    • Reputation: +29188/-596
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!2
  • No Thanks!0
  • In fact, I would also point out that constant reminders about the Crisis are kind of stupid, if your whole congregation is well aware.

    "Novus Ordo Watch" and such websites come to mind. Some people (recent converts to Tradition?) need that "pull" to help them make a clean break from their (recent) Novus Ordo life. But most Trads do NOT need this.
    That's why I never visit Novus Ordo Watch, or any site like it. It's not aimed at me, or people like me. I have moved on DECADES ago, and am interested in living a good Traditional Catholic life, 24/7, in this messed-up modern world.
    I don't need the play-by-play of the latest madness in the Conciliar Church. It serves no purpose for me.

    Most Trads are well aware there's a Crisis in the Church, and have no temptation to go follow the modern Popes and Conciliar madness. Occasional reminders are sufficient.

    I would even say that 100% constant harping on the Crisis is a bit dangerous. Every Trad is "good" in this category. But what about all the various virtues? What about opposing the World in other ways besides the Novus Ordo? What about advancing our prayer life, committing 0 sins/week, or serving God with all our heart and soul? We're a lot less "good to go" in those areas, right? So which sermons are more COMFORTABLE for the average Trad? Sermons destroying Pope Francis or Pope Leo -- or sermons that force us to admit that we still need work?

    A priest who never challenges his parishioners to improve themselves spiritually is dangerous and self-serving, in my opinion.
    Want to say "thank you"? 
    You can send me a gift from my Amazon wishlist!
    https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

    My accounts (Paypal, Venmo) have been (((shut down))) PM me for how to donate and keep the forum going.

    Offline Pax Vobis

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 12349
    • Reputation: +7847/-2433
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • In fact, I would also point out that constant reminders about the Crisis are kind of stupid, if your whole congregation is well aware.

    "Novus Ordo Watch" and such websites come to mind. Some people (recent converts to Tradition?) need that "pull" to help them make a clean break from their (recent) Novus Ordo life. But most Trads do NOT need this.
    That's why I never visit Novus Ordo Watch, or any site like it. It's not aimed at me, or people like me. I have moved on DECADES ago, and am interested in living a good Traditional Catholic life, 24/7, in this messed-up modern world.
    I don't need the play-by-play of the latest madness in the Conciliar Church. It serves no purpose for me.

    Most Trads are well aware there's a Crisis in the Church, and have no temptation to go follow the modern Popes and Conciliar madness. Occasional reminders are sufficient.

    I would even say that 100% constant harping on the Crisis is a bit dangerous. Every Trad is "good" in this category. But what about all the various virtues? What about opposing the World in other ways besides the Novus Ordo? What about advancing our prayer life, committing 0 sins/week, or serving God with all our heart and soul? We're a lot less "good to go" in those areas, right? So which sermons are more COMFORTABLE for the average Trad? Sermons destroying Pope Francis or Pope Leo -- or sermons that force us to admit that we still need work?

    A priest who never challenges his parishioners to improve themselves spiritually is dangerous and self-serving, in my opinion.
    Right.  You could be the most die-hard-Trad and still lose your soul.  The moral law is still hard.  The obligations of praying and charity still exist.  Being a die-hard-Trad (i.e. not a heretic) is step 1.


    Offline Colt

    • Newbie
    • *
    • Posts: 7
    • Reputation: +0/-9
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • Quote from: Matthew 2025-08-06, 11:24:27 AM
    I would say the exact opposite. Priests like Fr. Pfeiffer are also problematic: they OBSESSES with "the fight" to the point they are constantly fighting, EVEN WITH THEIR FELLOW-PRIESTS WHOM THEY SHOULD BE ALLIES WITH.
    And they have been adversarial and "fighting" for so long, they forgot what they are even fighting for. They can't even remember the "basics" of how to live a Catholic life -- basic Ascetical & Mystical theology. Bitter zeal has become a way of life.

    We all admire the "fighters" who name names, speak truth to power, fight against whoever they have to, in pursuit of truth and righteousness. The modern-day heroes and martyrs.
    But once in a while you have to put down your sword and pick up your rosary, and in general foster a deep and real PRAYER LIFE.

    As someone above pointed out, these topics of basic Catholic life are EVERY BIT AS IMPORTANT as naming the Jew, criticizing the Pope/SSPX/etc. or any other "fighting" or controversial topic.

    You can't leave out these basic topics, just because there is a Crisis.

    Personally, I think priests like Fr. Pfeiffer are a sad collateral damage from the Crisis in the Church. Imagine forgetting how to just stop and be Catholic. Just stop and serve God, meditate on the life of Our Lord, the Blessed Virgin, enjoy a good Catholic hymn, enjoy the beauty of God's creation, offer praise to God -- you know, stop and "live". Especially doing things constructive (helping new converts, mentoring young Catholics, volunteering at a Trad chapel, etc.) We shouldn't lose sight of these positive things because we've been fighting a bitter fight for so long.

    It reminds me of a soldier who has been at war for 10 years and can barely remember what he was fighting for. He can no longer enjoy most of what he is "defending" in the war -- he has lost all taste for actual day-to-day life in the country he left to fight.
    I completely agree that bitter zeal is a real danger, and I never meant to promote that. But to clarify, I never mentioned Fr. Pfeiffer, nor do I follow him. My concern was not about any individual priest. It was about the need for clarity from the pulpit in the midst of a real and ongoing crisis in the Church.

    The saints were not just contemplatives. They were confessors, defenders, and martyrs. Their deep interior lives gave them the strength to speak clearly when it cost them everything. Prayer and combat were never separate. The more they loved God, the more they stood for His truth.

    Basic Catholic spirituality is absolutely essential. But it does not exist in a vacuum. Today there are many Catholics who appear devout, who pray and attend Mass, but who remain silent or confused in the face of doctrinal collapse. It is not enough to be pious, not when error is preached from the pulpits and accepted as normal.

    We are not in ordinary times. We are in a battle. And in a battle, the faithful need both interior strength and clear direction. No one is asking for confrontation in every sermon. But we do need to be reminded often of what we are up against, because the war is real and it touches every soul. That is not bitterness. That is fidelity.

    It is also worth noting, with sadness, that more than half of the faithful who once stood with Father Girouard now attend fully conciliar SSPX chapels. That is not because they stopped praying. It is because they stopped hearing the truth.



    Offline Pax Vobis

    • Supporter
    • *****
    • Posts: 12349
    • Reputation: +7847/-2433
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0
  • It is also worth noting, with sadness, that more than half of the faithful who once stood with Father Girouard now attend fully conciliar SSPX chapels. That is not because they stopped praying. It is because they stopped hearing the truth.
    There are over 100 hours a week where an avg person is awake.  A sermon usually lasts 1 hr or less.  So at most, a sermon accounts for 1% of one's weekly time.  Daily prayer should account for a LOT more than this.  

    Anyone who is part of the new-sspx and who doesn’t see their liberalization isn’t praying well enough.  God speaks to the soul much better and more clearly, through prayer, than any sermon.  Your criticism of Fr is wrong. 

    Offline Colt

    • Newbie
    • *
    • Posts: 7
    • Reputation: +0/-9
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!1
  • Quote from: Miseremini 2025-08-04, 9:50:23 PM
    The people to whom Father addressed this sermon are well aware in detail of the crisis that is tearing the Church apart and are informed of every new infraction that comes along by Father.
    Their souls need the ammunition to fight, which Father also gives them.
    If Father is warning souls privately, then why have so many of his former faithful returned to the conciliar SSPX? Has he publicly called them back?

    Now that Father Rusak is heading to the Northwest Territories, who will replace him in Langley? A Novus Ordo priest with no conditional ordination?

    Souls do not just need private support. They need public clarity. And silence in times like these is not clarity. It is confusion.



    Offline Mat183

    • Newbie
    • *
    • Posts: 70
    • Reputation: +38/-7
    • Gender: Male
  • Thanks!0
  • No Thanks!0


  • Now that Father Rusak is heading to the Northwest Territories, who will replace him in Langley? A Novus Ordo priest with no conditional ordination?



    Good Fr. Rusak!  I remember him as the only SSPX priest that I know of who hosted Robert Sungenis at his chapel in Winnipeg to give a talk to his flock about the truth about geocentrism as well as setting up a debate between Dr. Sungenis and another individual on that subject at the University of Manitoba.  The university audience was generally hostile to Sungenis, but by the end of the debate he had actually won most of them over to his side as evidenced by their vote on who won the debate.

    Fr. Rusak had also daringly posted a strongly critical commentary under his own name on The Angelus book site's comment section regarding a fellow SSPX priest's notorious book.  The book was Fr. Robinson's The Realist Guide to Religion and Science.  In spite of the politeness, not to mention the objective correctness of the commentary, it was removed from the site within a matter of days while I think all the "cheerleading" commentaries were left up.