CathInfo.com

(If I missed anyone or if you have updated info, please advise.)


Fr. Urutigoity (ringleader):
removed as vicar general  (second in command of the diocese) in cuidad el este, argentina, last I heard (2014).  He currently has no ministerial assignment, and resides somewhere in the Diocese of Ciudad del Este, according to a diocesan spokesperson. He remains a priest in good standing.  Photographed in a children's missal: https://michaelbaumann.wordpress.com/tag/st-john-society/
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0974174815/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=0974174815&linkCode=as2&tag=httpwwwchanco-20 />
Fr. Dominic Carey:
replaced Fr. Urutigoity as vicar general.  Carey, a Canadian whose affiliation with the SSJ dates back to the early 1990s, before the group was ousted from the Society of St. Pius X and settled in Scranton, Pennsylvania, would go on to become the SSJ’s main fundraiser.  He still listed as vicar general in cuided el este, argentina.

Fr. Eric Ensey (second ringleader):
MIA since 2014
thought to be living in Rome and California as late as 2007.  In 2011, the Vancouver Sun reported that for the previous five years a Vancouver priest, John Horgan, had been soliciting donations from parishioners for the Society of St. John in Paraguay—at Ensey’s behest.  Ensey filed for bankruptcy in 2004; the case was terminated in 2010. His latest attorney of record reported that he has not had “any contact with him in years.” Ensey apparently maintains a P.O. box outside Scranton. After exhausting his appeals in the canonical case against him that began a decade ago, Ensey was finally laicized in 2014.

Fr. Dominic O’Connor:
original members of the Society of St. John who succeeded Urrutigoity as superior of the Society of St. John, asked Bishop Martino for permission to relocate to the Diocese of Nottingham in 2005. He remains there still.  http://lmslincolnshire.blogspot.com/p/recent-high-mass-at-louth.html

Fr. Daniel Fullerton:
became superior general after O’Connor, received Martino’s permission to serve as a chaplain to the U.S Navy.

Fr. Joseph Levine:
another former superior general of the SSJ, sought ordination as a priest of the Diocese of Scranton. But Martino was not comfortable with Levine’s “generous verbal excuses for the conduct of some members of the Society of St. John."  Levine was eventually assigned to a parish in Philadelphia, but his public support of the SSJ caused “quite a stir,” according to Martino, and he had to be moved to another parish—where the same thing happened. Levine decided to seek ordination to the priesthood in the Diocese of Paterson, New Jersey, but an open letter to the bishop brought that plan to a halt. Levine was eventually ordained a priest, and he now serves as pastor of a parish in the Diocese of Baker, Oregon.  https://stpeterstd.org/about-us/#staff

Fr. Marshall Roberts:
early member of the SSJ, vacated the Diocese of Scranton without permission, became the pastor of a group in Jacksonville, Florida, was kicked out, and is now in Boston, KY.  (search cathinfo for info on him)

Fr. Basel Sarweh:
early member of the SSJ, asked to be dispensed from the clerical state in 2006.

Fr. Anthony Myers:
When he worked with the SSJ in Scranton, he was Br. Anthony Myers.  Myers moved to Ciudad del Este with other SSJs and was ordained by Livieres in 2006. He authored several of the Society’s newsletters after the group had reestablished itself in Paraguay. But it seems that Myers no longer exercises his ministry exclusively in Ciudad del Este. In late 2013, he posted a video to YouTube seeking financial support for a new endeavor—a co-ed bilingual K-12 school on the outskirts of Buenos Aires.   https://performasports.com/case-studies/post.php?s=2017-05-08-presidente-franco-rugby-club

Fr. Paul Carr:
ordained a FSSP priest in 1992 and served as a member of the faculty at the FSSP’s Our Lady of Guadeloupe Seminary and a chaplain at St. Gregory’s Academy (where the SSJ began). In 2000, Carr became the District Superior of the North American FSSP and was succeeded by Fr. George Gabet.

I nearly joined this group. I met them when they were still at St. Gregory’s Academy. I went to Shohola the following year, with many reservations after reading things about them. I spent one night at the new residence and what I saw and heard (I will not bear repeating) was enough to make me leave the very next day. All of the postulants that arrived around the same time as I did all ended up leaving within a few weeks, I was later told. I flew across the continent one day (Alberta to PA) and the next day, having been given a ride by a young gentlemen on his way to Philly, flew out to California to visit with an elderly Italian trad couple I met years before. I needed time to unwind and ponder possibilities before returning home. Thanks to our Lord, His Mother and my guardian angels, I was spared.

You could tell after one day there was something wrong with the place.  For anyone to spend any length of time there is either very naive or a pervert themselves. 
Birds of a feather tend to flock together.

(If I missed anyone or if you have updated info, please advise.)


Fr. Urutigoity (ringleader):
removed as vicar general  (second in command of the diocese) in cuidad el este, argentina, last I heard (2014).  He currently has no ministerial assignment, and resides somewhere in the Diocese of Ciudad del Este, according to a diocesan spokesperson. He remains a priest in good standing.  Photographed in a children's missal: https://michaelbaumann.wordpress.com/tag/st-john-society/
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0974174815/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=0974174815&linkCode=as2&tag=httpwwwchanco-20 />
Fr. Dominic Carey:
replaced Fr. Urutigoity as vicar general.  Carey, a Canadian whose affiliation with the SSJ dates back to the early 1990s, before the group was ousted from the Society of St. Pius X and settled in Scranton, Pennsylvania, would go on to become the SSJ’s main fundraiser.  He still listed as vicar general in cuided el este, argentina.

Fr. Eric Ensey (second ringleader):
MIA since 2014
thought to be living in Rome and California as late as 2007.  In 2011, the Vancouver Sun reported that for the previous five years a Vancouver priest, John Horgan, had been soliciting donations from parishioners for the Society of St. John in Paraguay—at Ensey’s behest.  Ensey filed for bankruptcy in 2004; the case was terminated in 2010. His latest attorney of record reported that he has not had “any contact with him in years.” Ensey apparently maintains a P.O. box outside Scranton. After exhausting his appeals in the canonical case against him that began a decade ago, Ensey was finally laicized in 2014.

Fr. Dominic O’Connor:
original members of the Society of St. John who succeeded Urrutigoity as superior of the Society of St. John, asked Bishop Martino for permission to relocate to the Diocese of Nottingham in 2005. He remains there still.  http://lmslincolnshire.blogspot.com/p/recent-high-mass-at-louth.html

Fr. Daniel Fullerton:
became superior general after O’Connor, received Martino’s permission to serve as a chaplain to the U.S Navy.

Fr. Joseph Levine:
another former superior general of the SSJ, sought ordination as a priest of the Diocese of Scranton. But Martino was not comfortable with Levine’s “generous verbal excuses for the conduct of some members of the Society of St. John."  Levine was eventually assigned to a parish in Philadelphia, but his public support of the SSJ caused “quite a stir,” according to Martino, and he had to be moved to another parish—where the same thing happened. Levine decided to seek ordination to the priesthood in the Diocese of Paterson, New Jersey, but an open letter to the bishop brought that plan to a halt. Levine was eventually ordained a priest, and he now serves as pastor of a parish in the Diocese of Baker, Oregon.  https://stpeterstd.org/about-us/#staff

Fr. Marshall Roberts:
early member of the SSJ, vacated the Diocese of Scranton without permission, became the pastor of a group in Jacksonville, Florida, was kicked out, and is now in Boston, KY.  (search cathinfo for info on him)

Fr. Basel Sarweh:
early member of the SSJ, asked to be dispensed from the clerical state in 2006.

Fr. Anthony Myers:
When he worked with the SSJ in Scranton, he was Br. Anthony Myers.  Myers moved to Ciudad del Este with other SSJs and was ordained by Livieres in 2006. He authored several of the Society’s newsletters after the group had reestablished itself in Paraguay. But it seems that Myers no longer exercises his ministry exclusively in Ciudad del Este. In late 2013, he posted a video to YouTube seeking financial support for a new endeavor—a co-ed bilingual K-12 school on the outskirts of Buenos Aires.   https://performasports.com/case-studies/post.php?s=2017-05-08-presidente-franco-rugby-club

Fr. Paul Carr:
ordained a FSSP priest in 1992 and served as a member of the faculty at the FSSP’s Our Lady of Guadeloupe Seminary and a chaplain at St. Gregory’s Academy (where the SSJ began). In 2000, Carr became the District Superior of the North American FSSP and was succeeded by Fr. George Gabet.

Fr Paul Carr was ordained by the SSPX in 1992. He then moved over to the FSSP.
Some years ago I heard that he was with the local Novus Ordo diocese but living at his family home in England. How true this was I cannot say