This thread https://www.cathinfo.com/sspx-resistance-news/an-honest-question-for-those-inclined-against-the-resistance/ prompts the question.
We would like Rome to say V2 is completely null and void. But humanly speaking, that's probably not going to happen. An orthodox Rome could rescind some V2 docuмents and issue authoritative interpretations of others. It also could impose some sacrifices, such as requiring traditional bishops to function as priests, not bishops.
What would and wouldn't be acceptable to you to end the crisis?
It would have to include at minimum these 20 actions:
1. Restoring The index (which would mean a reverse Index, practically speaking, since there's so much trash out there, including what's been written by aberrant theologians). The index would be "Everything," minus Exceptions. "Everything" would include all the modernism that passes for Catholicism within the second half of the 20th century and forward from there. Better yet, there would be two indices: One regarding Religion; the other for secular works.
2. A formal repudiation of the Second Vatican Council -- its docuмents, its language, its vagueness, its residual "spirit," its informal outgrowths that became passively "institutionalized," such as CITH, secular musical instruments at Mass, etc. Elimination of RCIA. Conversions are restored 1:1 to the local priest. (Already true in my parish.)
3. The restoration of traditional liturgy, in Latin -- not a "Latinized" NOM. This would be universal decree, including for mission territories. The NOM would be declared illicit and those celebrating or attending it in schism.
4. The restoration of traditional authority in the Church, which means exclusively male (clerical) governance.
5. The dismantling of the diocesan bureaucratic structure and its de facto lay control. The episcopacy is reduced and simplified to what is essential for the bishop to carry out his appointed mission and no other role, such as Public Relations Man, politician, etc.
6. With that ^, the elimination of the secular alliances the Church has forged in the last 60 years with "causes" and organizations whose purposes oppose the moral teachings of the Church or do not relate in any way to the salvation of souls. #5 and #6 will also free up a ton of money.
7. Restoration of the 1917 Canon Law and enforcement of it.
8. Restoration of all traditional apostolates and orders that have been persecuted under Francis and/or by particular bishops.
9. Restoration of traditional sacramental rites (all, including their appropriate names: Penance, not "Reconciliation"; Extreme Unction, etc.)
10. Mandatory re-institution of religious rank and respect. The end of priests wearing secular garb; religious women wearing modern clothing. Habits, collars, etc. Titles of respect.
11. Re-instruction of men educated in N.O. seminaries. They will have to learn Latin, the traditional sacramental rites, and traditional doctrine, and be tested on it before being declared suitable for ministry.
12. The closing of orders of women which refuse to re-align with Tradition in teaching, mission, and lifestyle. The end of religious women living singly; mandatory re-institution of community life.
13. Re-examination of the mission of orders and communities that have abandoned their foundress' intentions. They will be restored to their original mission or closed.
14. Automatic approval of orders of women dedicated or re-dedicated (reverting) to nursing, teaching, and running private orphanages.
15. The re-naming of Catholic schools and colleges which are not aligned to Tradition and teaching orthodox Catholicism exclusively in the religion curriculum, or the reshaping of them to conform to Tradition.
16. Bonfires for the CCC. Return of the St. Pius X Catechism for laity, the Council of Trent catechism, etc.
17. Return of the midnight fast, the pre-1962 Lenten disciplines (abstinence, fasting), etc.
18. Official restoration of all pre-V2 Catholic devotions.
19. Removal of images of V2 papal "saints" on church grounds. Demoting of their feast days on the traditional calendar. No official promotion of devotion to them; removal of their names from liturgical prayers.
20. Return of the deliberate role of the Church as singular witness to Truth in the public square.