Author Topic: What are the chances of Williamson reuniting with SSPX? (Read 10814 times)

2Vermont · « **Reply #20 on:** September 17, 2015, 06:24:18 PM »

Quote from: Neil Obstat

Quote from: 2Vermont
Except both Bishop Fellay and Bishop Williamson don't seem to take issue with Catholics attending the NO.

That's a lie, and you know it. Attempting to stir up controversy, now?

Or, when you said, "I'm beginning to think you just like to argue for the sake of argument," were you thinking of yourself?

.

Actually it's not a lie and you know it. Or are you one of the folks who deny or explain away that Bishop Williamson advised a woman to attend the NO in June?

Moorslayer · « **Reply #21 on:** September 17, 2015, 09:20:35 PM »

Quote from: 2Vermont

Except both Bishop Fellay and Bishop Williamson don't seem to take issue with Catholics attending the NO.

Well IDK about Bp. Fellay's position in particular but I know the SSPX officially warns against attending the NO.

(I don't like Voris he just mentions what I'm talking about)

Neil Obstat · « **Reply #22 on:** September 18, 2015, 03:39:31 AM »

Quote from: 2Vermont

Quote from: Neil Obstat
Quote from: 2Vermont
Except both Bishop Fellay and Bishop Williamson don't seem to take issue with Catholics attending the NO.

That's a lie, and you know it. Attempting to stir up controversy, now?

Or, when you said, "I'm beginning to think you just like to argue for the sake of argument," were you thinking of yourself?

.
Actually it's not a lie and you know it. Or are you one of the folks who deny or explain away that Bishop Williamson advised a woman to attend the NO in June?

No, it's a lie and you know it.

Bishop Williamson did not advise a woman to attend the N.O., but only explained to everyone publicly that he did not advise AGAINST her doing so, for personal reasons applicable only to her case and to others like her. He was very clear in saying that he does not recommend the N.O. for everyone, and that it constitutes an objective danger to the faith of Catholics in general. Maybe you should pay better attention.

.

2Vermont · « **Reply #23 on:** September 18, 2015, 04:13:33 AM »

Quote from: Neil Obstat

Quote from: 2Vermont
Quote from: Neil Obstat
Quote from: 2Vermont
Except both Bishop Fellay and Bishop Williamson don't seem to take issue with Catholics attending the NO.

That's a lie, and you know it. Attempting to stir up controversy, now?

Or, when you said, "I'm beginning to think you just like to argue for the sake of argument," were you thinking of yourself?

.
Actually it's not a lie and you know it. Or are you one of the folks who deny or explain away that Bishop Williamson advised a woman to attend the NO in June?

No, it's a lie and you know it.

Bishop Williamson did not advise a woman to attend the N.O., but only explained to everyone publicly that he did not advise AGAINST her doing so, for personal reasons applicable only to her case and to others like her. He was very clear in saying that he does not recommend the N.O. for everyone, and that it constitutes an objective danger to the faith of Catholics in general. Maybe you should pay better attention.

.

OK,so you are one of the blind ones who likes to explain it away. No matter how you slice it, Bishop Williamson didn't tell her NOT to attend. No trad cleric should ever do that.

JPaul · « **Reply #24 on:** September 18, 2015, 08:24:09 AM »

Neil O,

Quote

Bishop Williamson did not advise a woman to attend the N.O., but only explained to everyone publicly that he did not advise AGAINST her doing so, for personal reasons applicable only to her case and to others like her. He was very clear in saying that he does not recommend the N.O. for everyone, and that it constitutes an objective danger to the faith of Catholics in general.

I must protest. "and that it constitutes an objective danger to the faith of Catholics "
Full Stop! The Church forbids a Catholic from knowingly placing themselves where a danger to the Faith exists.
We can go no further at that point, and I do not see any possible circuмstance where that does not apply, and therefore any counsel which controverts this is wrong and should not have been given.

She came for permission and absolution from something that she suspected or knew was wrong and she received both and others who are of the same mind did as well.

Very Bad.