So should resisters go by Matthew's "gut feeling" about what is good enough, or should they expect a traditional bishop to follow the ritual precisely and exactly?
The question should be repeated: Have you made any effort to express this concern to the Bishop himself?
What purpose does it serve to discuss a new bishop's possible mistakes with us rather than simply passing the information on him?
For Green Scapular, anything to score a point for "the team" or cost "the other team" a touchdown is fair play.
It's all team spirit for him.
In other words, he'll do anything and everything to discredit the Resistance.
Pretty desperate if you ask me.
Remember, Our Lord laid out very precise guidelines for fraternal correction.
1. Correct the person (privately)
2. Bring others with you and correct him again, so every word is coming from 3+ mouths in unison -- it has more force.
3. Tell the Church. If they won't hear the Church, consider them an infidel or heathen.
I'll grant that in 2015, "tell the Church" would be "tell CathInfo" or "post it on the Internet", since the institutional Church is in complete disarray and in a state of being conquered.
But to jump right to #3 so you "won't lose your chance" to discredit the Resistance -- that shows bad will.