Quote from: Telesphorus

Neotrads aren't even remotely Christians.

The Remnant is a neotrad rag.

Just to clarify:

There is a certain attitude that is unmistakable, and can be found among many supposed traditionalists.  They say things not out of ignorance, but with manifest lack of reverence for the Catholic Faith.  Their priorities are very clearly not with Catholicism.  They typically show themselves to be engaged to some extent with today's popular culture but most telling of all they show their true loyalties by showing their brusque contempt for those opposed to feminism, liberalism, zionism, "neo-conservatism" in general.

Some are genuinely ignorant.

However, those who write about Traditionalism in newspapers are not -except with a few exceptions - ignorant of what's really going on.

Traditionalism for them is a social identity connected to their family life.  

And for them the goal is to adapt Traditionalism to their social needs.

And their social needs often revolve around fitting in with Republican liberals (ie "conservatives") or the equivalents overseas, Novus Ordo "pro-lifers" etc. (not to knock pro-lifers, but the conciliar church is not strongly pro-life)

For them traditionalism is politics.  It's their way of participating and enlarging themselves.  And while some may actually have a sentimental attachment to the religion - it's very apparent that they are primarily interested in manipulating the people who actually have the Faith to suit their ends.  And invariably they betray their complete departure from the traditionalism of the Archbishop and really from Catholicism into a kind of neo-traditionalism, which is about (in the US) Republican Catholicism.