J. Paul,
I appreciated your and Holly's comments on the resistance thread. I believe that you are undertaking a good work by trying to bring to light the overarching problem with the traditionalist movement as a whole.
Your soul is Catholic and so is your thinking.
To answer your question: The conciliar sect is the ѕуηαgσgυє of satan, and antichrist, and quintessentially not Catholic. Were it Catholic we would never have gone out from the visible structure, which it captured and enslaved, to upbuild the Church and transmit the Faith in the hinterlands.
The Catholic Church has one mark, which is the summa of the Four Marks; and that is the mark of the transmission of the Faith. Wherever the Faith is transmitted, there is the Church - because it is impossible to transmit the Faith without the Mystical Union of the Head with His Members: the Vine with the attached branches.
It its Holy Essence, the Church is a fecundity.
Now does the conciliar sect transmit the Faith? A resounding 'no' is the answer. The conciliar sect has for its raison d'etre to abort the Faith before it can come to fruition in souls and/or to murder it in souls who once believed. Ergo the conciliar sect is not the Church.
As you are so wise to point out, too, too many traditional priests are content to fiddle with puerile, internecine grudges and grievances while the Church burns to the ground, were that possible.
There has come into the world an indescribable and manifold abyss of satanic error, which the Church is ordained by God to engage in mortal combat. You talked about the need for the formation of a new and dynamic Catholic order, not some retread of the old SSPX, to defend against the onslaught of error choking the very life out of the lungs of the all the nations.
Let's face it - the SSPX, good though it was, did not defend against all the errors. It mainly defended against the errors of religious indifferentism. It never waged war against the heresy and schism of theological, philosophical, and scientific evolution, which is the arch principle of the revolution against the Lord and against His Christ.
The hour is late. Five more years of SSPX-style "defense" of the Faith, and the world of 2013 will look like Christendom.
Either we seriously re-calibrate and start defending the entire deposit of the Faith - either we attack the errors of scientism head on - or God will pour down fire from Heaven to purge the earth of all the filth.