Pope Pius XII did consecrate Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary, only without all the world's Bishops. Roscoe thinks this was sufficient while all the followers of Gruner think it was not.
All one can conclude is this: If Pius XII made the proper consecration of Russia in 1952(?), then the Fatima message is a hoax. The children were deluded, or just plain lying. The promise of a period of peace was altogether made up. The Church has been deceived by this hoax. Because Pius' alleged "consecration" did not produce the promised results.
I believe that Fr. Gruner was right. Furthermore, I believe that Roscoe is, well, an ass. No offense, Roscoe.