Here’s the boys all in shorts:
I don't find this to be a big deal per se. Shorts go to their knees and in some cases cover them. I just think that the SSPX is going too far to show themselves to be "with it" and "cool" and not totally hostile toward secular reality. There's a fine line between this and becoming worldly. So, for instance, let's advertise all the "fun" we have at seminary, and all the "cool" things our priests do. None of this stuff ever draws people to the Church. Why? It's because people have enough of the world in their daily lives. They are drawn to the Church precisely because it draws them and lifts them OUT OF and ABOVE the world. I don't go to Mass to experience crappy third-rate music. I'd rather listen to "good" music at home. There used to be a cartoon series called
King of the Hill. One of the most memorable lines from that show came when the main character's son decided to start a Christian rock band. His father replied: "Bobbie, you're not making Christianity better. You're making rock-n-roll worse." All you get here is a very bad imitation of the world.
And here's the lesson that these new generations of SSPXers do not get ... because they did not grow up with it. Listen well, youngsters: THE NOVUS ORDO ALREADY TRIED THIS, and it was an EPIC FAILURE that not only did not draw people into the Church, but even had the opposite effect, of losing countless souls back to the world. I think this is the fruit of a younger generation of Trads who grew up knowing only Tradition. They have not learned the lessons from watching the Novus Ordo play out ... and implode in slow motion before their very eyes.. So they are doomed to repeat it ... naturally speaking. I remember being shown a video during my Novus Ordo High School days where the narrator was mocking the Tridentine Mass over how the priest had his back turned to the people and "mumbled" in a language they couldn't understand. But they made the mistake of showing footage from a Tridentine Mass. And I was absolutely awe-struck by the Mass. This, I knew, was what my soul and my mind had always longed for. So it had the opposite effect on me from what was intended. From that point on, I went in search of this Mass.
I've also known some younger priests who play basketball with the young men of the parish. Does this ever draw people to the Church? No, it usually leads to a loss of respect for the priest and the priesthood. I've known priests who palled around with their parishioners. But people don't need another drinking buddy. They need a spiritual director, someone they can look up to and respect, not someone that they lose respect for by seeing all their faults up close and personal. I used to say to my brother, who, like myself, was an ex-seminarian, that it's a good thing lay people don't ever spend time living at the seminary, since they'd never again have any respect for priests. It's not easy to maintain that respect when you see people with all their warts and their failings.