Of all the allegations in Catholicus' initial post, the only one that Manuel is in a position to deny is about the contents of his room. Catholicus stated that he had some nefarious book and some "voodoo" items on his desk. Manuel denies that the book was on his desk ... but books move. As for "voodoo" objects, they could simply be personal artifacts, and the purpose for having them and the use he was making of them might not be evident just from seeing them.
It was afterwards that Incredulus and RevolveBooks both posted that Pablo asks people for pictures of themselves and their families and puts them on the wall purportedly to pray for them. So two people other than Catholicus testified to that.
As for everything else in Catholicus' posts, you were in no position to deny them, Manuel.
You categorically denied it all, but you were not present when these things allegedly took place. So you actually are not in a position to deny them, and thus your overreach.
Now could the soup incident have been misconstrued and the origin/nature of the phone calls misunderstood? Certainly. Could Pablo actually be using the pictures to help him pray for the individuals in them? Of course. My mother does the same thing with the pictures of her children and grandchildren.
But you cannot prove that these things did not happen, only that at the time you cleaned Pablo's room you did not find anything overtly related to witchcraft in there. That's it. Based on that, however, you proceed to deny everything.
So right now we have Cathoicus' word -- and Incredulus' and RevolveBooks' word about the photos -- vs. your word. Your unfounded denials have no probative value. At best you can only say that, well, you found no materials/objects overtly related to witchcraft in his room at the time you cleaned it. That's it.
Now, here to me is the best indication that Catholicus was at least sincere in reporting what he thought he had witnessed and/or experienced. If he were entirely fabricating the stories, he could make up far bigger doozies than a few incidents that are open to interpretation. He could have said that he found an upside down crucifix on a Rosary Pablo was carrying around, along with a pentagram in his desk drawer. He could have made up all kinds of things. So, because he didn't come up with more, this suggests that it's sincere.