Seraphina’s testimony answered all the questions before I had to ask them.
You did not ask the same degree of questions, and she did not provide them. You were asking Catholicus for the name of the restaurant and specific dates. You didn't grill Seraphina about the exact dates of these incidents nor did she provide them. You didn't ask her questions akin to where the cigar holes were, i.e. what color the alleged bathrobe was, etc. So this is nonsense.
If I were staying in a strange place, I would not necessarily recall the layout of the place. If I was eating at a restaurant I did not frequent regularly, I would probably not be able to recall its name even days later, much less months. Catholicus bowed out because of your hostile grilling. You did your job by eliminating a potential source of information against Pablo.