Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

« previous next »
Pages: 1 [2]

Author Topic: Another Bishop "excommunicates" faithful who go to SSPX Masses  (Read 4138 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Adolphus

Another Bishop "excommunicates" faithful who go to SSPX Masses
« Reply #5 on: November 03, 2014, 09:19:52 PM »
Quote from: hollingsworth
Quote
-Que la “Fraternidad Sacerdotal San Pío X” no cuenta al presente con una “posición canónica” en la Iglesia y que por ello no ha de ponerse en su misma situación a quienes en la diócesis de Zárate-Campana se acogen conforme a las normas del derecho a la forma extraordinaria del rito romano, de la carta de S.S. Benedicto XVI dada motu proprio“Sumorum Pontificuм”.


I think it's pretty straightforward.  Paraphrased it reads something like this:

The SSPX does not at present have a "canonical position" in the Church, and for that reason, (their priests)  can not be placed in the same situation as those (priests?) in the diocese of Zarate-Campana who do conform to the norms established under the extraordinary form of the Roman rite,  rfrom the letter of Benedict XVI given in (his) motu proprio Sumorum Pontificuм

Yes, that's what it intends to express.  But the way it was redacted in Spanish is really bad.
Logged

Offline Maria Auxiliadora

  • Supporter
Another Bishop "excommunicates" faithful who go to SSPX Masses
« Reply #6 on: November 04, 2014, 05:39:18 AM »
Quote from: Adolphus
Quote from: hollingsworth
Quote
-Que la “Fraternidad Sacerdotal San Pío X” no cuenta al presente con una “posición canónica” en la Iglesia y que por ello no ha de ponerse en su misma situación a quienes en la diócesis de Zárate-Campana se acogen conforme a las normas del derecho a la forma extraordinaria del rito romano, de la carta de S.S. Benedicto XVI dada motu proprio“Sumorum Pontificuм”.


I think it's pretty straightforward.  Paraphrased it reads something like this:

The SSPX does not at present have a "canonical position" in the Church, and for that reason, (their priests)  can not be placed in the same situation as those (priests?) in the diocese of Zarate-Campana who do conform to the norms established under the extraordinary form of the Roman rite,  rfrom the letter of Benedict XVI given in (his) motu proprio Sumorum Pontificuм

Yes, that's what it intends to express.  But the way it was redacted in Spanish is really bad.


The part that caught my attention is:
Quote
-Que la “Fraternidad Sacerdotal San Pío X” no cuenta al presente con una “posición canónica” en la Iglesia y que por ello no ha de ponerse en su misma situación a quienes en la diócesis de Zárate-Campana se acogen conforme a las normas del derecho a la forma extraordinaria del rito romano, de la carta de S.S. Benedicto XVI dada motu proprio“Sumorum Pontificuм”.


 It seems to be saying that since the SSPX has no canonical status, they do not have the right to the "EF" according to the norms of SP.
Logged

Offline Adolphus

Another Bishop "excommunicates" faithful who go to SSPX Masses
« Reply #7 on: November 04, 2014, 08:10:00 PM »
Quote from: Marie Auxiliadora
The part that caught my attention is:
Quote
-Que la “Fraternidad Sacerdotal San Pío X” no cuenta al presente con una “posición canónica” en la Iglesia y que por ello no ha de ponerse en su misma situación a quienes en la diócesis de Zárate-Campana se acogen conforme a las normas del derecho a la forma extraordinaria del rito romano, de la carta de S.S. Benedicto XVI dada motu proprio“Sumorum Pontificuм”.


 It seems to be saying that since the SSPX has no canonical status, they do not have the right to the "EF" according to the norms of SP.


Well, in some sense, that is what the docuмent says: that, since the SSPX currently does not have a "canonical position" in the Church, it cannot place itself in the same situation (or at the same level, to say so) of the diocesan priests, who do conform to the norms established under the EF.
Logged
Pages: 1 [2]
« previous next »