Having a N.O. publisher and foreword weren't the worst of the problems with this book, apparently. Fr. Robinson gave a copy of his book to the brother of a friend of mine. That brother is a traditional priest (not SSPX or FSSP, though). He was "heartbroken" to see that an SSPX priest could put out such a text: In the book Fr. R. says something about protestants having an unrealistic view of creation. But that unrealistic view described is the traditional Catholic view as well. I'm paraphrasing from a conversation with my friend, but I'm sure I got the gist of this right.