It’s one thing to compile solid evidence that a man has committed a crime. It’s quite another to accuse a broad group of men, and by strong implication, an entire priestly society, of being guilty, by act and by concealment, of awful crimes.
There may be a lot of people here who are disappointed at the SSPX leadership’s lack of courage in the face of modernist Rome’s attempts to soften their opposition, but few of us believe the whole society is a vile den of perverts and sodomites, which is exactly what CM’s piece insinuates.