What is the Essex PX resistance, and why does piano man want them investigated? Sounds British.

I was told 'Dr K' had, for a while at least, played the organ at the SSPX chapel in North London and that is how he originally met Fr Paul Morgan.

As has been said above by Ladislaus there needs to be a clarifying statement by Bp Morgan confirming (a) appropriate safeguarding checks were made WRT Kelly/Ciaran Moran and (b) whether he was ordained sub-conditione and by whom.  That would settle the issue.

Ok, now it's all making sense.  Piano guy was probably buddy-buddy with +Williamson.  But now that +W is gone (+RIP) and Bishop Morgan is in charge, the dynamic of things changed.  Piano guy's relationship with the Resistance changed once +Morgan took over, and he's not happy.  Just like when a new CEO comes into a company, things are done differently.  Happens all the time.

That theory doesn't seem to fit imo. Even if Piano Man decided he hated Bp Morgan, he wouldn't be able to simply fabricate this Fr. Moran situation.

It's shocking that he's been able to cover it up for so long, regarding Fr. Moran. How?


Martinique, where he was based, is French territory. It is to France what Puerto Rico or Hawaii is to the US. Having him convicted and tried and jailed in either France or Ireland wouldn't be hard.

How long was it, though?  From what I read Moran was put on trial / investigation in 2022 and finally convicted in June 2024.

Clearly Piano Man isn't being emotional AT ALL here...

Plenty of us are married, so... not involuntary celebate.
I may not have a stone chapel like he has, or a six figure income from Youtube, but I do have a house with 5 acre property, so... not in my mom's basement.
Most CI members have normal homes -- not living with parents.

CI members hold a wide variety of views and opinions on just about everything. We are not cult members, who all adhere to the same opinions/views. We all think for ourselves. We don't all agree on anything, except maybe the Catholic Faith.

But he's wrong about ANY of us being tolerant of ANY level of child abuse or sɛҳuąƖ deviancy in the clergy. We are as intolerant of this as he COULD EVER PRETEND to be.

To be charitable, I will call out Piano Man for being very SUPERFICIAL and IGNORANT regarding his whole attack on CathInfo. He really needs to get a clue about what CathInfo is, and what the "SSPX Resistance" is. Because he is currently laboring under some SERIOUS ignorance.

Yeah, he appears to be snowflaking out here due to what began as very mild and subtle criticism, and then making strawmen like we're all attacking him in order to run cover for Bishop Morgan and to condone whatever malfeasance he may be guilty of.  Sounds like his ego has been bruised, and now he's lashing out making false accusations, things that evidently he could be arrested for over there ... as per your debunking of his claims above here, Matthew.

I'd say Piano Dude is slandering us by claiming that we condone predation upon children, quite the contrary.  He should grow up and realize that we're just trying to get the facts before dragging Bishop Morgan out, lynching him, or, over there, drawing and quartering him in the public square.  Many people have been subjected to flase accusations, ruining their good name ... and we simply do not want to commit such a grave injustice.

I'm sure that every single poster here, to a person, would be outraged if in fact it were established that Bishop Morgan had been knowing working with a predator who has not only been credibly accused by even found guilty in formal proceedings.  I'd be calling for his arrest, personally.

So this whole notion of circling the wagons to defend predation upon children ... that's completely false and slanderous.

If Piano Man keeps it up, we should consider bringing a defamation lawsuit against him, eh? ... since he has a huge audience.

Mr. Piano Man, please make a retraction of some of your false and defamatory accusations against us, or else you may be the subject of a defamation suit.

I don't think anyone says he's fabricating the "Fr. Moran situation".  What we don't know and has only been promoted by little evidence, and mosly by insinuation ... is Bishop Morgan's role in the matter.

If you have a better hypothesis, I'm all ears. But for now, that seems to be the most likely explanation.

Well, one hypothesis, Matthew, is that you set this whole thing up precisely in order to get Piano Man to send traffic to CathInfo ...   If so, well played.