No, not muddying waters; only separating what is certain and what only may be. I think the whole situation is very dangerous at the moment particularly the idea of a personal prelature which locks the Society in a submission to Rome for the whole future. bp Fellay thinks this pope has great good will towards us (I don't, incidentally) but who knows what a pope in the future would do.
Sorry about the dig! If I seriously thought forums were bad I wouldn't be in one! :sign-surrender: :sign-surrender: