Now we're talking. Where has the Church given us evil, even in non-infallible circuмstances? There is no precedent.
You must be joking. The Church led the flock into error in 1616 by defining a heliocentric reading of the Bible was formal heresy,
or
the Church led the flock into error in 1835 when popes allowed the flock to read and believe in a heliocentrism and that the Bible can be read with an interpretation contrary to the unanimous opinion of all the Fathers.