Author Topic: Interpreting the words of Abp Lefebvre (Read 6836 times)

Klaus · « **Reply #15 on:** May 22, 2012, 08:02:30 PM »

Quote from: Seraphim

Quote from: Klaus
Could you flesh out the syllogism there? Think you might be missing a premiss or ten.

Klaus-

I must say, I enjoy the sarcasm.

No doubt we will not see eye to eye in whatever threads we encounter eachother, but your wit is enjoyable, even when directed against me.

:tv-disturbed:

Thanks, but I will try to be nice! :dancing-banana:

Telesphorus · « **Reply #16 on:** May 22, 2012, 08:09:45 PM »

Quote from: Klaus

The difference is that Bp Fellay was alive in 2009, and Abp Lefebvre was not. Excommunications are medicinal penalties which only apply to the living.

So you believe the excommunications were valid? Yes or no?

Quote

Note that all four bishops had their excommunications lifted, not just +Fellay.

It could not have been done otherwise. There was no difference in the cases of the four bishops, and there was no "repentance" - at least not officially.

We really have no idea what Bishop Fellay has promised.

SeanJohnson · « **Reply #17 on:** May 22, 2012, 08:21:58 PM »

Quote from: Klaus

Quote from: Seraphim
Quote from: Klaus
Could you flesh out the syllogism there? Think you might be missing a premiss or ten.

Klaus-

I must say, I enjoy the sarcasm.

No doubt we will not see eye to eye in whatever threads we encounter eachother, but your wit is enjoyable, even when directed against me.

:tv-disturbed:

Thanks, but I will try to be nice! :dancing-banana:

Mind if I ask if you are a priest?

Kelley · « **Reply #18 on:** May 22, 2012, 08:40:22 PM »

Quote

The author, Fr. Gregoire Celier, is a priest of the Society of St. Pius X. Ordained in 1986, he is the author of many books and over 500 articles.

Here is some background on Fr Celier...

1.) GREC, whose purpose "inconspicuous but not secret" is the reconciliation of the SSPX and Rome

2.) Fr. Celier is the priest who authored the scandalous book Benoît XVI et les traditionalistes.

3.) Fr. Gregoire Celier's disturbing book, Benoît XVI et les Traditionalistes was edited and had its introduction written by a Jean-Luc Maxence who is a contributor to the official journal of the Grand Orient of France, La Chaine d'Union and an author of other masonic works and almost certainly a mason himself

Quote from: Maurice Pinay

Fr. Gregoire Célier is (was) reportedly also on Bp. Fellay's commission for the "discussions" with Rome ...

And while Bp. Williamson remains essentially gagged and bound for the "crime" of "h0Ɩ0cαųst denial" and is smeared worldwide for "neonαzι" associations, it appears that Fr. Gregoire Celier has received no correction or censure for his masonic associations and is (was) still involved with the "dialogue" with Rome.

There's a certain policy and direction implied in all of this which is very disturbing.

Klaus · « **Reply #19 on:** May 22, 2012, 08:47:37 PM »

Quote from: Seraphim

Quote from: Klaus
Quote from: Seraphim
Quote from: Klaus
Could you flesh out the syllogism there? Think you might be missing a premiss or ten.

Klaus-

I must say, I enjoy the sarcasm.

No doubt we will not see eye to eye in whatever threads we encounter eachother, but your wit is enjoyable, even when directed against me.

:tv-disturbed:

Thanks, but I will try to be nice! :dancing-banana:

Mind if I ask if you are a priest?

Not at all! I'm not.