Some readers might think I should be offended that someone found a problem in
one of my ideas. On the contrary, I am delighted! This is the whole point here.
Let's talk about these things, and make our mistakes NOW, when it doesn't matter.

Let's hash it out! Let's come up with some wild new, out-of-the-box zingers!

You just know that these men are huddled in dark rooms wishing and hoping
that they can pull a fast one. They want secrecy and they thrive on it. That's
because they have some deep, dark secrets that they don't want to be known
and they don't want them to be brought up in a Q&A setting. Sede Catholic is
right on the money. Let's get ready for the task of reading between the lines.
If they come a-visiting and find that even 5% of the crowd is armed to the
teeth, it can't help but have an effect on what they have to say. Be ever-vigilant
to discover the real reason he's showing up at this time: what's he trying to
accomplish here?

Be ready for the smokescreen, for the "ack-ack." Watch out for conspicuous
drifting off topic by way of telling cute stories. I doubt that Fr. Rostand can be
as clever or as slick as +Fellay, but you know he's going to try. Be ready for it.

As I explained before, think proactively. Have several well-built men posted at
the exit doors so the speaker can't make a hasty escape. Someone should
guard the back door past the bathroom so he can't say, "I'll be right back," and
try to run off instead of using the loo. Be wise as serpents and gentle as doves.

Quote from: Neil Obstat

...
 Sede Catholic is right on the money.
...
 

Thank you, Neil.

You're most welcome! And thank YOU! This is what I'm talking about.

Let's get these ideas out on the table and get a plan together. Anyone who reads
these posts might have their own approach. Perfect! Let the grace of God work
in you and let's find an answer to some of the probing questions. Something
really odious is going on behind closed doors, and it's time it got flushed out
into the open so we can all take a good long look at it..

............... whatever it is!







I'd better be quiet now --------- looks like Matthew is having a nap....  :rolleyes:

Please know I don't expect anyone should send this list of questions to Fr. Rostand.
He probably has them already anyway. HAHAHAHA

 

I am writing these questions for others who may need to compile their own, to be ready with a clear mind when Fr. Rostand comes to town for a friendly town hall meeting. That is the only point.

I agree.


I think it's a good idea, because I for one always think I have good questions for priests (in general) and then when I see them, my mind draws a blank.  Of course, the list is only of use to a point, because I think it is appropriate to do as Matthew & Mater did, and ask questions based on his talk:   pin him down on things he says.  e.g. If he says +BW has changed, make him say on exactly what points, and cite what +BW supposedly believed before, and supposedly now.  If he mentions "rumors" on the internet, try to pin him down on exactly what rumors?  etc.

And I am glad you took my clarification in the spirit in which it was meant - because, exactly as you said, "We should be very careful getting our facts straight because the adversaries are just waiting for a little mistake, so then they can focus on that one thing and ignore all the other things."  Exactly.

I've noticed, Gertrude, that your posts tend to be rubbish.

They're supposed to be rubbish, he's the resident CI troll.

He was not calling me a troll, gertude.

He was calling YOU a troll.

So, gertrude, you are possibly even dumber than I thought.

Quote from: Sede Catholic

I've noticed, Gertrude, that your posts tend to be rubbish.

They're supposed to be rubbish, he's the resident CI troll.

 :applause:

Yes, I agree with you.

gertrude's posts are rubbish.

And he is a troll.

Bishop Fellay's ilk (such as his right-hand man, Fr. Rostand) will be going to many of the SSPX chapels and try to swing the situation. These priests need to learn some common sense.

SJB, you are also an acquaintance of John Lane.

Perhaps you should inform him that this gertrude character is allowing the forum to believe that he, gertrude, is John Lane.

It seems that that is something YOU should do.

If you have any regard for John Lane, you will do that.