Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

Author Topic: Fr. Rostand comes out Swinging  (Read 6790 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Fr. Rostand comes out Swinging
« on: October 02, 2012, 09:57:50 PM »
I saw this on IA earlier, it looks like Fr. Rostand has decided to spew some more garbage:

http://www.sspx.org/District_Superiors_Ltrs/2012_ds_ltrs/september_2012_ds_ltr.htm

Quote
Dear Friends and Benefactors,

Returning from the General Chapter of the Society of St. Pius X, I would like to thank you for your generous prayers for the intentions of this important meeting.

The Chapter, gathering all superiors and elder priests of the Society, went very well. As you may have already read in the official declaration of the Chapter, a profound unity was recovered - unity in our essential mission, unity in our actions, as well as unity of government under our Superior General, His Excellency Bishop Bernard Fellay.

This is a great grace for which we must be very grateful. Once again, thank you for your prayers.

It is now time for us to reflect on the events of the past few months, and why this unity was shaken in some.

The first reason is obviously the delicate situation we are in. Our relationship with Rome has always been a sensitive and complicated situation. However, it is not the first time we have had to deal with such complex affairs. So how did it become, for at least a few, so uncomfortable that some lost confidence in the Society and, in particular, our Superior General?

Looking back on those events, it is clear that there was an organized agenda on the part of some, intending to destabilize the Society of St. Pius X. For years, some small groups - with increasing aggression in recent months - have attacked and tried to undermine the Society. The Superior General and those who supported him were criticized from every angle. Everything was analyzed, not to find the truth, but in order to sow division. It is obvious that some have used every means they could to plant discord within the Society.

The first avenue used was to discredit the superiors; to lead step by step to a loss of confidence. They used continual attacks, calumnies, and distorted truths, repeating them again and again, following the well-known revolutionary adage: “Lie, lie, something will always remain.” This means that by repeating false accusations, something will eventually be believed as true; little by little, these attacks sunk into the minds of some.

This trend is nothing new. For years, primarily sedevacantist websites have disseminated their poisonous venom with the goal of dividing and even, if possible, destroying the Society of St. Pius X. For years they have accused, in a most fallacious way, that Bishop Fellay governs the Society with a small group of priests, with the majority of priests opposed. They allege that Bishop Fellay wants to “sell out” the Society; that his goal is not the restoration of the Church or of Tradition - but to betray the work of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre. They spread the rumor that the Society has already betrayed its founder. For years they have prophesied that Bishop Fellay is going to compromise.

All these rumors and false accusations have been spread on the Internet with many insults.

Over the past months, during which these attacks have intensified, it is noteworthy that most of the “indiscretions,” “leaks” and rumors about the Society were released on sedevacantist sites and newly-opened sites animated by the same spirit.

The fury and relentlessness of these attacks - and for the most part, anonymously - is clearly obvious. They have demonstrated by their work of destruction how they are, in reality, enemies of Tradition and of the restoration of all things in Christ the King. They try to appear in sheep’s clothing, but in reality they are wolves trying to scatter and divide the flock. They in fact show more hatred toward the Society than the anti-Catholic media!

I caution the faithful not to be deceived - especially on the Internet. Please be aware of “cyber-gossip” which is even more damaging than if it is done in person because it can be done anonymously and because of how many eyes it can reach in a short period of time. As a matter of fact, “cyber-gossiping” should be taken as a moral fault and as seriously as any kind of rumor, not only in spreading them but in going after them as well.

The declaration of the General Chapter shows once again, and against all the false prophecies, that the Society of St. Pius X remains united behind our Superior General. The Society remains faithful to its essential mission and to the work and spirit of our founder Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre.

The United States District will continue to inform you faithfully and truly on our websites (sspx.org and dici.org) about the fight for the restoration of all things in Christ the King.

With my prayers and blessing in the Immaculate Heart of Mary,

Fr. Arnaud Rostand

Fr. Rostand comes out Swinging
« Reply #1 on: October 02, 2012, 09:59:46 PM »
Quote from: Fr. Rostand
The Society remains faithful to its essential mission and to the work and spirit of our founder Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre.


Um, I don't think so. Attempting to sell-out to Rome (and expelling anyone who speaks out against a "reconciliation") is NOT remaining faithful to the work and spirit of Archbishop Lefebvre.


Fr. Rostand comes out Swinging
« Reply #2 on: October 02, 2012, 10:03:19 PM »
Quote
“Lie, lie, something will always remain.” This means that by repeating false accusations, something will eventually be believed as true; little by little, these attacks sunk into the minds of some.


You are the liars, this is why the sermons of the Archbishop are suppressed.

It was Bishop Fellay himself who said his acts could split the society!

There is nothing more odious, or hateful, than perfidy.  And do not think that we ever cease to expose that perfidy.

We will never forget this betrayal.




Fr. Rostand comes out Swinging
« Reply #3 on: October 02, 2012, 10:38:28 PM »
Quote from: Father Rostand
with the goal of dividing


Quote from: Bishop Fellay
“There are some discrepancies in the society,” said Bishop Bernard Fellay. “I cannot exclude that there might be a split.”


Bishop Fellay went against the advice of the three bishops, and started making moves that would have put the SSPX at the mercy of the conciliar establishment, which he himself admitted could cause a split.

He is the one who was working to bring about a result that would send the Archbishop's work to ruin, without regard for the damage and confusion and opposition it would provoke from his own priests and bishops.

Quote from: Archbishop Lefebvre:
What bishop? - A bishop that would meet the Vatican's requirements? In that case, they will have a bishop who gently, gently will bring them round to the Council - that's obvious. They will never obtain a bishop who is fully Traditional, opposed to the errors of the Council and to the post-Conciliar reforms. That is why the Fraternity of St. Peter did not, in fact, sign the same protocol as we did, because they do not have a bishop.


And indeed, in Bishop Fellay, now the SSPX has such a bishop, whereas the other three bishops, who are told to shut-up

Quote from: Archbishop Lefebvre
Once again, I do not think it possible for a community to remain faithful to the Faith and Tradition if the bishops do not have this Faith and fidelity to Tradition. It's impossible. Say what you will, the Church consists first and foremost of bishops. Even if the priests are of your way of thinking, the priests are influenced by the bishops. Whichever way you look at it, the bishops make the priests, and so guide priests, either in the seminaries or in preaching or in retreats or in any number of ways. It is impossible to maintain Tradition with progressive bishops.


How often have we heard Bishop Fellay speak of requests for SSPX "help" - who can but roll their eyes at this talk?

Quote from: Archbishop Lefebvre
Such things are easy to say. To stay inside the Church, or to put oneself inside the Church - what does that mean? Firstly, what Church are we talking about? If you mean the Conciliar Church, then we who have struggled against the Council for twenty years because we want the Catholic Church, we would have to re-enter this Conciliar Church in order, supposedly, to make it Catholic. That is a complete illusion. It is not the subjects that make the superiors, but the superiors who make the subjects.


And then there are the lies, the suggestion that so many of the non-sedevacantists are really "practical sedevacantists" - because they don't unquestioningly follow Bishop Fellay!  Why the Fellay apologists have come on this forum and asked us "where is the visible Church"  

Quote from: Archbishop Lefebvre
This talk about the "visible Church" on the part of Dom Gerard and Mr. Madiran is childish. It is incredible that anyone can talk of the "visible Church", meaning the Conciliar Church as opposed to the Catholic Church which we are trying to represent and continue. I am not saying that we are the Catholic Church. I have never said so. No one can reproach me with ever having wished to set myself up as pope. But, we truly represent the Catholic Church such as it was before, because we are continuing what it always did. It is we who have the notes of the visible Church: One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic. That is what makes the visible Church.


We could go on and on and on and on.

But what these people can do is never answer the argument, and never stop shifting their positions, and they are the ones who rely on never-ending calumnies - as they flagrantly disregard what the Archbishop taught.

Fr. Rostand comes out Swinging
« Reply #4 on: October 02, 2012, 10:49:24 PM »
Anyone who wants to see the flagrant contradictions that the neo-SSPX has been making should read the posts of Berengaria on Ignis Ardens forum.

They are excellent.  I really wish user posts could be more easily searched there.