If I see someone commit a murder, I know that they are a murderer

If I hear someone say something heretical, I know that they are a heretic

You are guilty of a sin when you commit it. A sentence of guilt from the state or Church merely confirms that you are responsible for the crime

And you tell me. And then I find out it was actually self-defence and that what YOU thought you saw was in fact not quite the whole picture. This is why we have trials and do not let the individual string someone up to the nearest tree.

These 'ipso facto' penalties do not come from you. They are spiritual and come form God. God decides, not you. We cannot attempt to read another mans soul without a proper trial. It's that simple. Again, you can say that his works smacks of heresy etc but YOU cannot declare him a heretic and try and get everyone else to declare him a heretic as you would be stepping outside your competence and committing the sin of usurpation as outlined by St. Thomas Aquinas. All your justifications have no place here.

No.  Not all ipso facto are spiritual.  It’s in canon law, which is human law. 

You’re basically arguing the same thing as Siscoe/Salza.  Nothing happens until the Church decides.  So that means (stupidly) that Biden and Peℓσѕι are Catholics in good standing. 

Ladislaus, is Boru either Sisco or Salza??

You sir are extremely vocal and aggressive about getting everyone to desert the Church, leave the SSPX, leave the Resistance even, and become a Sede-vacantist like yourself. What is your real agenda?

Perhaps you need a lesson in basic catechism: Article IX, The Catechism of the Council of Trent, TAN book:

"First, as St. Augustine observes, the Prophets spoke more plainly of the Church than Christ, foreseeing that on this a much greater number may err and be deceived than on the mystery of the Incarnation. For in after ages there would not be wanting wicked men, who, like the ape that would fain pass for a man, would claim that they alone were Catholics, and with no less impiety than effrontery assert that with them alone is the Catholic Church."

"For a person is not to be called a heretic as soon as he shall have offended in matters of faith; but he is a heretic who, having disregarded the authority of the Church, maintains impious opinions with pertinacity."

"The Church..as the scriptures and writings of the Saints testify, includes within her fold the good and the bad..Hence there are but three classes of persons excluded from the Church's pale: infidels, heretics and schismatics, and excommunicated persons...but with regard to the rest...even the lives of ministers debased by crime, they are still within the Church, and therefore lose nothing of their power."

"...the Church is known and is compared to a city built on a mountain, and visible from every side. As all must yield obedience to her authority, it is necessary that she be known by all."

"The Church has but one ruler and one governor, the invisible one, Christ, whom the eternal Father hath made over all the Church, which is His body; (and) the visible one, the Pope, who as legitimate successor of Peter..fills the Apostolic chair."

"St. Jerome...'Following no chief but Christ, I am united in communion with your holiness, that is, the chair of Peter. I know that on that rock is built the Church. Whoever will eat the lamb outside this house is profane; whoever is not in the ark of Noah shall perish in the flood'."

"Christ (is) not only the author of all the Sacraments, but also their invisible minster - He it is who baptizes, He it is who absolves...although men are appointed by Him the external ministers of the Sacraments...so has He placed over His Church, which he governs by His invisible Spirit, a (visible) man to be His vicar and the minister of His power. A visible Church requires a visible head..."

"Be careful to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace; one body and one Spirit."

In 1884, satan challenged Christ to test His Church. Pope Leo XIII heard him ask for 100 years. Christ agreed.
In 1884 the Fabian society (Fɾҽҽmαsσɳɾყ by infiltration) was set up to infiltrate government, schools and the Church. Agents by the hundreds were sent undercover to flood these establishments. The plan? Stealth mode; pretend to be what you are not in order to slowly change the establishment to your way of thinking from within. Thanks to Pope Pius X, this test was checked somewhat and calmed the storm. But the enemies resurfaced at Vatican II.  This is a test. What we are going through is that very test that Christ agreed to. Its a test of faith, of trust and a test of loyalty. It is the flood of old. We know what the Church is. The Body of Christ; visible and invisible. Head and members. Good and bad. Peter and Judas. And as it is divine, it is indefectable and eternal. Satan could only touch the human element; he could not touch the divine.

Since around 1984, the traditional movement within the Church has blossomed. Satan failed as Christ knew he would. The storm has been receding and its only a matter of time before the Church regains her former glory.

We must stay with the Ark and ride out the final throes of the debasing storm.

Before posting again, Borat ... recalling that it's a lie to sin ...

1) Are you Salza, Siscoe, or some close ally to one of these?

2) Are you the poster formerly known by various names, such as Xavier, XavierSem, Nishant, and others ... or someone associated with him?

3) Do you even attend SSPX chapels or are you an "Ecclesia Dei" type ... FSSP / ICK/ Motu, one of those "approved" varieties?