Author Topic: Fr Marshall Roberts with the Resistance (Read 30920 times)

Ladislaus · « **Reply #45 on:** May 15, 2015, 08:44:10 PM »

Quote from: Elizabeth

It is extremely unwise to single out the SSPX as THE group capable of being infiltrated by ɧoɱosɛҳųαƖs.

No, I did nothing of the sort. I was only commenting vis-a-vis the subject of this thread. I strongly suspect many non-SSPX priests of being ɧoɱosɛҳųαƖs as well. I don't have proof, so I avoid naming names. Just my "gαydar" at work.

Ladislaus · « **Reply #46 on:** May 15, 2015, 08:49:34 PM »

Quote from: Pilar

Lamb, I am in total agreement. As soon as I read Lad's post, I was absolutely floored that he didn't seem to be picking up on the irony of his comment! What you have said is more worrisome for the Resistance than anything I have yet read.

No irony, just a refusal to make inferences that could be tantamount to a grave sin of calumny.

stbrighidswell · « **Reply #47 on:** May 16, 2015, 12:17:29 AM »

Quote from: LAMB

Quote from: Ladislaus
I could very well get kicked off of CI for saying this, but truth is truth.

We ruthlessly excoriate the NO bishops who constantly shuffle around the predator priests and thereby enable future predations.

There's a disturbing trend here with the SSPX, and yet nobody really wants to talk about it.

Father Urrutigoity was accused of such behavior by the SSPX's own rector at La Reja. Yet not only did Father U gain admittance into Winona, but he was protected and even promoted there almost as if he were the right-hand man of the rector. He was allowed to build up a cult following there, an inner circle, despite +Lefebvre asking that he be watched like a hawk, especially if he tried to form "particular friendships".

Now we see Father Roberts. When I was at Winona, the rumor was already there at the seminary about why he had gotten kicked out of ICK. Yet he found a new home at Winona also.

Both Urrutigoity and Roberts were ordained despite these clouds hanging over them. As far as I can tell, they must have had their protectors within the SSPX.

Something stinks within the ranks of the SSPX. I suspect infiltration by the ɧoɱosɛҳųαƖs (as well as, most likely, various modernist plants).

Now one guy was kicked out while I was there because his mannerisms were "offensively effeminate" (the exact words used by Bishop Williamson upon letting him go). But perhaps he had not found any protectors as of yet (he had only been there a week or so).

I think that you need to look a little closer to home Ladislaus. Who was the rector in Winona at the time of Urrutigoity and Roberts? Who welcomed Urrutigoity into Winona in the first place, despite the pleadings of the rector of La Reja, Fr. Morello, who had kicked him out for predatorial homo behaviour?

It is a fact that a Resistance priest was sent to Ireland in January 2015, to a family of 11, to say Mass on a monthly basis, who had been permanently deprived of his public ministry by the SSPX, because of 2 separate homo predatorial allegations. the second incident involving a 14 year old French boy. This priest was sent to Ireland from Queen of Martyrs House in Broadstairs by his current superior, who did not see fit to inform the said family and when they were informed by a member of the Faithful in March, this priest agreed not to return to Ireland again. This priest still has a public ministry in the UK, with the full approval of his superior, who has put his approval in writing.

I can 100 % confirm what is written here about the Resistance priest. The faithful were left in absolute shock over this. The priest was asked not to return again and I have seen an email where Bishop Williamson has said that the faithful in this resistance church have denied themselves a good priest albeit a little flawed.
This does not negate the necessity of the Resistance but my confidence in Bishop Williamson is shot. down thumb all you like

Franciscan Solitary · « **Reply #48 on:** May 16, 2015, 12:47:30 AM »

Below is a highly relevant quote concerning the topic of this thread that is taken from the earlier CI thread "Restoring the Bastions: The Church Militant at War" contributed by "nipr" in 2013. This is very likely the best and most thorough presentation of this topic available. Those who read or contribute to this current thread ought to read it with feelings of humble gratitude to so fine a Roman priest as Fr. Marshall Roberts and then weep at the heartless ingratitude of men. The truth presented here concerning Fr. Roberts only makes this writer yearn to have the Catholics be rid of Jansenist heretics like "Pepe" even more.

And may the Good Lord forgive us for the many slanders contained in this current thread against His beloved Roman priests:

Please read the following words most carefully and with an open mind and a respectful heart:

"I cannot watch this go on any longer without saying something. We went through this at Christmas and here we are again.

I realize most of you do not know Fr. Roberts. I understand your suspicion these days of any priest, especially one who has been accused of something horrendous. But I'd like to give you MY impression of Fr. Roberts.

I met this good priest last Fall. I was impressed from the first moment I met him at his chapel. I knew practically nothing of the allegations against him and after meeting him such suspicions never even crossed my mind.

Now mind you, in my working years I worked alongside openly gαy men because they happened to work for the companies I worked for. In a large city that is the case. So I have been well-acquainted with the characteristics of a gαy man.

In my years in the Church I have met priests whom I suspect were gαy because I saw the same characteristics in them.

I SEE NONE OF THIS IN FR. ROBERTS.

If there ever was a heterosɛҳuąƖ man who went by the book, it is he. There is NO funny business about him in any way whatsoever. I attend his Mass weekly and only regret that I cannot attend daily. His sermons are out-of-the-ballpark good--especially the one he gave for the Sunday near the Feast of the Sacred Heart about how little devotion there is to Jesus's Heart and how little loved He is. I haven't heard these kinds of sermons since I was a kid before Vatican II. He quotes Scripture. He quotes Canon Law. He refers to Tradition when asked why this or that or what to do in such-and-such a circuмstance. He is a walking encyclopedia of Church history, lives of the Saints, you name it.

I've been searching for 51 years for a priest to answer some personal (apply only to me) questions I've had and Fr. Roberts is the ONLY priest who has been able to answer them. Again, he quotes Jesus's words and explains how they apply in the situations I asked him about. No priest has ever been able to do this for me. AND HE MAKES PERFECT SENSE. The ability to guide a soul (and I understand I am not the only one) with such precision is totally incompatible with someone in the state of mortal sin. If you don't believe me, look in your theology books. It's there. I've gotten one crazy answer with no foundations for it from priest after priest until I met Fr. Roberts.

Not only do I know him from Mass and Confession, but socially as well. He is a delight to be around. I've spoken to him privately and in a group setting. He has a very well-rounded personality and his conversation is fascinating because of his intelligence and knowledge.

Father wears the full Dominican habit all the time. I do not know his standing in the Dominican Order. He has a Dominican Third Order group in Jacksonville, FL and is starting up a Discalced Carmelite Third Order group there as well.

I will tell you one thing: It is worth moving to Jacksonville, FL to have the God-given grace to have this priest for your Mass. I've seen 51 years of priests and this one is OUTSTANDING. He encourages us to take up our cross and follow Jesus, that the servant cannot be greater than the Master, that we should pray to become holy, that our attention should be focused on God dwelling within us (if we are in the state of grace and if not, to get to confession ASAP) and our eyes should be on Heaven and not on the things of this earth. He has told me many times to "accept suffering" as that proves love of God and to depend on Divine Providence to work out my difficulties in life. HE CAUSES ME TO REMEMBER WHAT BEING A CATHOLIC IS ALL ABOUT, which I thought I knew until I met this hard-hitter priest (in the sense of nothing is trivial if it offends God). And he will spend as long a time as needed with you in confession to set your soul at ease and he lets you ask as many questions as you want.

Now you can say this is emotional and not based in facts about the allegations, but let me say this: You can read the top theologian's books on what a priest should be and this priest is IT. I know. I've read the books and have been searching for such a priest all my life.

As for his possible "reformation" -- I can't possibly see what there could have been to "reform." (Pardon me if I am using the wrong term but if I try to go back to see what was posted I'll lose this page for sure.) We recently celebrated his 17th year of ordination. He recounted to us his history with the Society and the St. John's group, etc. As I recall, he said he didn't like what was going on at St. John's and left. I wish I had paid more attention but my mind was centered on how utterly deplorable it is these days that a good priest like Fr. Roberts should have to endure so many difficulties just to be a good Catholic priest.

I am suspicious of ALL priests as I've had some things happen to me in dealing with some that are too shocking to write here so I don't automatically place ANY priest on a pedestal just because he's a priest. I learned to not do that the hard way. I've watched Fr. Roberts for months just waiting for something shocking or unpleasant to happen and the more I get to know him, the more I admire him.

Let me say this: I've had cancer recently. I'm still in the time period when it is most likely to return. Should that happen, I hope and pray Fr. Roberts will be my priest when I'm on my deathbed. I want HIM to prepare me to be judged by God. I mean this sincerely. I don't know what higher recommendation I can give a priest."

Posted Jul 5, 2013, 8:36 pm

Elizabeth · « **Reply #49 on:** May 16, 2015, 01:18:36 AM »

Nipr has a very pure and loving Catholic heart.