Send CathInfo's owner Matthew a gift from his Amazon wish list:
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/25M2B8RERL1UO

« previous next »
Pages: 1 ... 10 11 [12] 13

Author Topic: Fr. Marshall Roberts Update?  (Read 57456 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline klasG4e

Re: Fr. Marshall Roberts Update?
« Reply #55 on: February 18, 2019, 04:51:44 PM »
Quote from: Matthew on February 15, 2019, 11:44:03 AM
Apparently there was some legal action in March 2018. Not sure if it is still ongoing.

But this is obviously public record, so it can be posted anywhere and everywhere.

Fr. Marshall Roberts
vs.
Mr. John Pfeiffer

In my opinion, I have SERIOUS doubts that Mr. Pfeiffer (a lawyer, I believe) would just, out of malice, make up all these things about Fr. Roberts. Why would he have such an axe to grind against a Trad priest. What, did Fr. Roberts run over his child, or at least his dog? What motive does Fr. Roberts suggest for Mr. Pfeiffer making all this up? I suppose something along the lines of, "He's pure evil, a child of the devil"? Give me a break! Let's be realistic here.

And it's not like Fr. Roberts had a reputation beyond reproach before Mr. John Pfeiffer came along. It's a fact that Fr. Roberts was with the Society of St. John, and a lot of scandals happened in that group. A lot of which is public record. AT LEAST there should be a cloud of suspicion over Fr. Roberts.

One can only imagine how much in legal fees and costs have already been generated over the last year with apparently no end in sight.

Update on case filed on 3-6-2018


Case Information Summary for Case Number
2018-L-002337
 

Filing Date: 03/06/2018Case Type: INTENTIONAL TORT
Division: Law DivisionDistrict: First Municipal
Ad Damnum: $50001.00Calendar: R
Party Information

Plaintiff(s)Attorney(s)
ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL MMUDD LAW OFFICES
3114 W IRVING PK#1W
CHICAGO IL, 60618
(773) 588-5410
Defendant(s)Defendant Date of ServiceAttorney(s)
PFEIFFER JOHN G05/21/2018OLP THOMAS G
1713 SHIRE COURT
WHEATON IL, 60189
(630) 220-7329

Case Activity

Activity Date: 03/06/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
INTENTIONAL TORT COMPLAINT FILED (JURY DEMAND)
Court Fee:598.00
Ad Damnum Amount:50001.00
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 03/06/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
EXHIBITS FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 03/06/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
SUMMONS ISSUED AND RETURNABLE

Activity Date: 03/06/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
CASE ELECTRONICALLY FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 03/09/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MA
POSTCARD GENERATED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES
Microfilm:LD000000000

Activity Date: 03/09/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
CASE MANAGEMENT DATE GENERATED
Date:05/02/2018
Court Time:0930

Activity Date: 03/21/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
EXHIBITS FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 03/21/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
EXHIBITS FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 03/21/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
NOTICE OF FILING FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 03/21/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
MOTION FOR APPOINTMENT OF SPECIAL PROCESS SERVER FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 03/22/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
APPOINT SPECIAL DEPUTY - ALLOWED -
Judge:MCWILLIAMS CLARE ELIZABETH

Activity Date: 04/02/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
NOTICE OF FILING OF PROOF OF SERVICE FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 04/17/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
APPEARANCE FILED - NO FEE PAID -
Attorney:MUDD CHARLES L JR

Activity Date: 04/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
APPEARANCE FILED - NO FEE PAID -
Attorney:JOAN M MANNIX LTD

Activity Date: 04/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
APPEARANCE FILED - FEE PAID - (JURY DEMAND)
Court Fee:467.00
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 04/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
CERTIFICATE FILED
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 04/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
NOTICE OF MOTION FILED
Date:05/08/2018
Court Time:1100
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 04/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
MOTION FILED
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 04/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
MOTION SCHEDULED
Date:05/08/2018
Court Time:1100
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 05/01/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
NOTICE OF MOTION FILED
Date:05/08/2018
Court Time:1100
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 05/01/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
MOTION SCHEDULED
Date:05/08/2018
Court Time:1100
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 05/02/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/02/2018Participant: ROBERTS
PRODUCE EXHIBITS OR OTHER RECORDS OR DOcuŠ¼ENTS OR PERSON - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/02/2018Participant: ROBERTS
STRIKE FROM CASE MANAGEMENT CALL - ALLOWED
Date:05/08/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/02/2018Participant: ROBERTS
CASE CONTINUED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE - ALLOWED -
Date:05/09/2018
Court Time:1030
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/08/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
APPEARANCE FILED - NO FEE PAID -
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 05/08/2018Participant: ROBERTS
STRIKE OR WITHDRAW MOTION OR PETITION - ALLOWED -
Date:05/08/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/09/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
EXHIBITS FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 05/09/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE APPEARANCE OR JURY DEMAND, ANSWER OR PLEAD - ALLOWED -
Date:06/12/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/09/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Date:06/12/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/09/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
CASE CONTINUED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE - ALLOWED -
Date:06/26/2018
Court Time:1000
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 05/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
SUMMONS - RETD P.S.
Date:05/21/2018

Activity Date: 06/19/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
MOTION TO DISMISS FILED
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
CONTINUANCE - ALLOWED -
Date:08/29/2018
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: ROBERTS
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Date:07/31/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Date:08/21/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: ROBERT
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
COURTESY COPIES REQUIRED - ALLOWED
Date:08/29/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: ROBERT
COURTESY COPIES REQUIRED - ALLOWED
Date:08/29/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
CASE CONTINUED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE - ALLOWED -
Date:08/29/2018
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 06/26/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
STRIKE OR WITHDRAW COMPLAINT, AMENDED COMPLAINT OR PORTION THEREOF - CNT -
Date:08/29/2018
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 07/30/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
NOTICE OF MOTION FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 07/30/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
MOTION FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 07/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
EXTEND TIME - ALLOWED -
Date:08/21/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 07/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Date:08/21/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 07/31/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Date:09/11/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 07/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
COURT DATE TO STAND - ALLOWED
Date:08/29/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 08/21/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
EXHIBITS FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 08/21/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
MOTION FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 08/23/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
NOTICE OF MOTION FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 08/23/2018Participant: ROBERTS
AMEND COMPLAINT OR PETITION - ALLOWED -
Date:08/29/2018
Judge:MCCARTHY, JAMES P.

Activity Date: 08/29/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 08/29/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE APPEARANCE OR JURY DEMAND, ANSWER OR PLEAD - ALLOWED -
Date:09/28/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 08/29/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 08/29/2018Participant: ROBERTS
AMEND COMPLAINT OR PETITION - ALLOWED -
Date:08/31/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 08/29/2018Participant: ROBERTS
CASE CONTINUED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE - ALLOWED -
Date:10/16/2018
Court Time:1000
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 08/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
CERTIFICATE FILED

Activity Date: 08/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
EXHIBITS FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 08/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 08/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
NOTICE OF FILING FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 10/09/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
MOTION TO DISMISS FILED
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: ROBERTS
CONTINUANCE - ALLOWED -
Date:10/31/2018
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Date:10/30/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Date:10/23/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: ROBERTS
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: ROBERTS
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: ROBERTS
STRIKE OR WITHDRAW MOTION OR PETITION - ALLOWED -
Date:10/31/2018
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: ROBERTS
COURTESY COPIES REQUIRED - ALLOWED
Date:10/31/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
COURTESY COPIES REQUIRED - ALLOWED
Date:10/31/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/16/2018Participant: ROBERTS
CASE CONTINUED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE - ALLOWED -
Date:10/31/2018
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/23/2018Participant: ROBERTS FATHER MARSHALL M
MOTION FILED
Attorney:MUDD LAW OFFICES

Activity Date: 10/30/2018Participant: PFEIFFER JOHN G
RESPONSE / REPLY - FILED
Attorney:OLP THOMAS G

Activity Date: 10/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
CONTINUANCE - ALLOWED -
Date:01/07/2019
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
EXECUTE OR PERFORM - ALLOWED -
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
COURTESY COPIES REQUIRED - ALLOWED
Date:11/02/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/31/2018Participant: PFEIFFER
COURTESY COPIES REQUIRED - ALLOWED
Date:11/02/2018
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
CASE CONTINUED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE - ALLOWED -
Date:01/07/2019
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 10/31/2018Participant: ROBERTS
STRIKE OR WITHDRAW MOTION OR PETITION - CONTINUED -
Date:01/07/2019
Court Time:1100
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 01/07/2019Participant: PFEIFFER
FILE AMENDMENT OR ADDITIONAL OR AMENDED PLEADINGS - ALLOWED -
Date:01/28/2019
Judge:LAWLER, CHRISTOPHER EDWARD

Activity Date: 01/07/2019Participant: ROBERTS MARSHAL
STRIKE OR WITHDRAW COMPLAINT, AMENDED COMPLAINT OR PORTION THEREOF - ALW -
[
Logged

Offline St Paul

Re: Fr. Marshall Roberts Update?
« Reply #56 on: February 20, 2019, 03:58:03 PM »
Quote from: klasG4e on February 18, 2019, 04:51:44 PM
One can only imagine how much in legal fees and costs have already been generated over the last year with apparently no end in sight.

Makes one wonder if fr. Pfeiffer informs benefactors where their money is spent.
I know for a fact he refuses to open his books when legally requested.  You've got to file a suit if you want to see his books, and there will be no guarantee you see the real books.
Do people know there isn't an OLMC "seminary" or "convent" 501c3?  That none of their donations are tax deductible?  Do they know OLMC doesn't have a bank account, that all money goes through an account in Mr. Hernandez' name?
Logged

Offline Matthew

  • Mod
Re: Fr. Marshall Roberts Update?
« Reply #57 on: February 20, 2019, 04:00:08 PM »
Quote from: St Paul on February 20, 2019, 03:58:03 PM
Makes one wonder if fr. Pfeiffer informs benefactors where their money is spent.
I know for a fact he refuses to open his books when legally requested.  You've got to file a suit if you want to see his books, and there will be no guarantee you see the real books.
Do people know there isn't an OLMC "seminary" or "convent" 501c3?  That none of their donations are tax deductible?  Do they know OLMC doesn't have a bank account, that all money goes through an account in Mr. Hernandez' name?

One of these days a benefactor is going to get randomly audited by the IRS (it happens, you know! Just not for those who make less than $50,000 a year. There just isn't enough potential payoff to make it worth the IRS effort of an audit), maybe they donated several thousand to OLMC which they deducted as a charitable contribution, and then the crap is going to hit the fan.
Logged

Offline Ladislaus

  • Supporter
Re: Fr. Marshall Roberts Update?
« Reply #58 on: February 20, 2019, 04:41:45 PM »
Quote from: Matthew on February 15, 2019, 01:38:14 PM
Mr. John Pfeiffer's lawyer (which might have been himself, since he is a lawyer) must have had a field day with this one.

All he'd need to do is show evidence, on the Internet and elsewhere, that suggests Fr. Roberts was not a "respected clergyman" as of dates that precede whatever statements John Pfeiffer made (specific exhibits that Fr. Roberts put forward as evidence against him).

I accidentally downthumbed this, when I meant to quote it.  Sorry.  But as admin you can fix that :-)

Indeed, the entire grounds for the suit is the damage done to Father Marshall's "reputation".  In point of fact, Father Marshall had LONG been under suspicion well before the statements made by John Pfeiffer.
Logged

Offline Wmt2020wmt

Re: Fr. Marshall Roberts Update?
« Reply #59 on: September 25, 2020, 11:41:58 PM »
Hi,
I realize this is an old thread, but I found it from googling Fr. Marshall Robert's name.  I was prompted to do some research when my parish which is in the Jackson Diocese sent out the following statement:

Statement on Fr. Marshall Roberts -- The Diocese of Jackson has issued the following statement yesterday:  

Father Marshall Roberts, an incardinated priest of the Diocese of Scranton, has reportedly assumed residence in Water Valley, Mississippi in the Diocese of Jackson. Since January 2005, Father Roberts has been unlawfully absent from priestly ministry in the Diocese of Scranton and does not have permission to exercise priestly ministry outside of the Diocese of Scranton. Furthermore, Father Marshall Roberts does not possess the faculty to validly hear confessions. Any inquiries about the priestly ministry of Father Marshall Roberts are to be directed to the Vicar General of the Diocese of Jackson: Reverend Lincoln Dall Chancery Building 237 E. Amite Street, Jackson, MS 39201 - 601-960-8476.

This brought-up many thoughts and feelings for me because our bishop, Joseph Kopacz, is also from the Scranton Diocese.  Bishop Kopacz knew that Fr. Lenin Vargas was defrauding parishoners at my home parish in Starkville, MS, and he did nothing to protect our parish.  I am so angry and unhappy with the bishop's response once some clergy went to the authorities and the investigation began.  He allowed Fr. Lenin to devastate our parish, and we have no recourse to even complain to church hierarchy about our bishop.  I would like to write to church oversight, if it exists.  Does anyone have any suggestions short of writing Pope Francis?
Logged
Pages: 1 ... 10 11 [12] 13
« previous next »