CathInfo.com

I believe he ran away from the SAJM Seminary in France. Then got ordained in Ireland where he didn't stay for very long after.

In 2015, I was among a small group who voiced concerns about Fr Ballini and his ideas, and how he planned to administer things in Ireland. At the time, we had no idea that he would secretly be made a bishop. Everyone else just accepted him because he was close and friendly to Williamson. Now we have ones given the authority of a bishop who, in ordinary times of the church, would not be bishops, and priests ordained by the resistance who ordinarily should not be ... or at least they should have been placed under close supervision. Instead, you see them given independent assignments in foreign countries.

The LifeSiteNews article references Fr. Hoopes' claim about new theology of jursidiction - that came from Bp. Roy - who was a +Williamson line Bishop. icarly never responded when I pointed out that Bill continued to go to Fr. Hoopes' mass until Fr. Hoopes departed to the fire station by claiming there are "difficulties" in the Church. All of these priests and Bishops come from +Lefvebre, not +Thuc.

+Roy was made a bishop in the +Thuc line, ordained in the +Lefebvre line

I would say the strongest evidence that cabbage and icarlytradcath are Fr. Hoopes is the strong and false claim that "Bill became a Thucist". Bill's favorite Bishops have been +Vigano and +Williamson. The LifeSiteNews article references Fr. Hoopes' claim about new theology of jursidiction - that came from Bp. Roy - who was a +Williamson line Bishop. icarly never responded when I pointed out that Bill continued to go to Fr. Hoopes' mass until Fr. Hoopes departed to the fire station by claiming there are "difficulties" in the Church. All of these priests and Bishops come from +Lefvebre, not +Thuc.

Besides, Fr. Hoopes' himself supports sedevacantist theology and "leans sede". So the claim that Bill would attempt to force Hoopes to be what he already claims to be is obviously false as well.

As shown in the LifeSiteNews article, one possible marker of Hoopes presence is that each person has been told a different story.

Moreover, cabbage and icarly are attempting to support the condemned judicial astrology book for "approved" divination purposes about the inclination of persons.

Also - this "Thucist" word seems to have originated from cabbage. The +Thuc line bishops, priests, and persons are not in the same organization, generally. The word is not helpful to the traditional catholic movement as it implies uniformity where it does not necessarily exist.

I don't think Carly is TGK or Fr. Hoopes. He seems to be a young convert who has some unusual interests. This isn't the first time I've interacted with him. I think sometimes he fails to understand while something may not be sinful, it doesn't necessarily mean one should have a strong interest in it like natural vs judicial astrology. It is one thing to understand the difference between the two things but in this crazy world we live in being able to find "legitimate outlets" is virtually impossible. Which is why people (including myself) seem to be flummoxed why he cares so much about it. Maybe he was bored one afternoon and he found it interesting.

Many on Cathinfo are older and are parents. I imagine no parents are interested in teaching their children the difference between astrological 'schools' and such. They have far more important things to teach their children. Catholicism\tradition covers so many topics. And astrology is not one of the overarching subjects discussed in tradition as far as I know. It seems relatively arcane. If I were a parent, I probably still wouldn't care to delve into this topic too much. It is much easier for me to give a cursory explanation on it and why it should be avoided.

I don't want to condemn him. But I do think he needs to realize that with tradition's long history with Pablo in Pffeiferville, and now with this Fr. Hoopes incident, people rightfully have their guard up. I first registered on here in 2017 and I hardly posted then. I did not post for many years after that because I didn't feel like I fit in or contribute much. Maybe Carly needs to take a step back and post less. Who knows.