Hooray for being naive and finding the good in the worst of criminals and sinners.
But Fr. Hewko is LITERALLY choosing Pablo el Brujo over the good Catholics of CathInfo. He is literally calling good "evil" and evil "good"!
He sees and understands that Pablo and the good Catholics of CathInfo are irreconcilable in their respective current states -- so whom does he castigate and call "evil"? The good Catholics of CathInfo.
That is not a small sin.
That is what I loudly, publicly, criticize Fr. Hewko for. It is a grave injustice and an inversion of everything the Priesthood stands for. Christ is Truth. It is *satan* who is the father of lies.
In fact, once your orientation is upside-down like that, it becomes the fountainhead of hundreds and even thousands of other sins.
Well said. Fr. Hewko criticizes Cath Info, but he apparently doesn't have a problem with Pablo, who's actions are far worse.
I'm not sure that it would work to have a trad priest or bishop oversee a forum like Cath Info. There are just too many divergent opinions in Tradition. Oversight may have worked in St. Pius X's day, but probably wouldn't work in a severe Crisis like what we have today.
Fr. Hewko doesn't agree with Bp. Williamson's stance on the New Mass. But there are probably others, even in the SAJM, who may not agree, but it isn't that big a deal. I don't think that +W requires that everyone agree with him on that issue.
Fr. Hewko seems to want a certain amount of perfection in a bishop, but he's not likely to find any who will live up to his standards. He may eventually realize that, and join up with the SAJM. It might take awhile. Though he can remain an independent priest too. He wouldn't be the only one.